|
FAMOUS NAME TILTING AT WINDMILLS IN MOULIN UNLESS GROUND
IS SOFT
FAMOUS NAME (39) easily blew by his rivals to take the
Group 3 Desmond Stakes in fast time. This was his third successive win in lesser
pattern company. But he's proven repeatedly that he's at least a borderline
Group 1 horse. So his connections must be very keen to gain that win at the top
level which will ensure his future as a stallion.
Personally I'm not sure exactly how Famous Name can secure
a Group 1 win this season. Trainer Dermot Weld may well be right that his best
trip is nine furlongs. But it looks like he needs softer ground to be fully
effective at a mile. This being so I'd be wary of supporting him for the Prix du
Moulin as the ground is invariably fast for that race. If he were mine I'd be
steering him towards the Premio Vittoria di Capua in October as the ground is
yielding or softer for the Italian Group 1 one year out of two. I'd also be
taking a long hard look at the Hong Kong Vase over ten furlongs in December. I
concede the ground is pretty much guaranteed to be firm for that race, but
Famous Name showed he's very effective on such ground over ten furlongs in the
Prix du Jockey Club.
I guess it's too much to hope that Famous Name will be kept
in training next year. But if he is the Dubai Duty Free would surely be a
tempting target as it's over his optimum trip of nine furlongs and is the
world's most valuable turf race. If he fails there he'd surely be able to land
that elusive win at the top level if campaigned in America. There are stacks of
Grade 1 races over nine furlongs there and the opposition in them is no better
than Group 3 in European terms.
CASUAL CONQUEST LACKS ACCELERATION
Rail movements at the Curragh can be so big that it's very
hard to interpret the times of races. This being so I wasn't that surprised to
discover that the Royal Whip Stakes won by CASUAL CONQUEST (41) was actually a
strongly run race despite the fact the time seemed slow in comparison with
shorter races on the card.
The front running Red Rock Canyon was nudged along to set
what was clearly a good gallop, and this is confirmed by the fact the winner
came home over three seconds slower for the final three furlongs than Famous
Name did in the Desmond Stakes. In addition his time was more than three seconds
better than the other ten furlong race.
Casual Conquest certainly looked good as he edged ahead to
win narrowly but a shade comfortably from the smart Curtain Call. The pair
rapidly went a long way clear of the rest as they dueled through the last three
furlongs.
The problem that Dermot Weld's star has is his lack of
acceleration.
Before his Group 1 win on heavy ground earlier this year
Casual Conquest's big claim to fame was his six length romp in last year's
Derrinstown Stud Derby Trial. But he beat a weak and suspect field there in a
race where the Coolmore pacemaker Hindu Kush did too good a job. That horse went
off so fast that every horse which chased him tired. This gave a big edge to
Casual Conquest who had been dropped out last. Basically everything tired badly
to run the final furlong in 13.2 seconds or slower. This allowed Casual Conquest
to simply lope past them all without having to accelerate.
Casual Conquest got totally outsprinted by Bronze Cannon on
his seasonal debut at Newmarket. And it was worrying how he got run down by a
couple of rather ordinary rivals in a Group 3 last time after kicking into the
lead a furlong and a half out.
It seems to me that unless the early pace is incredibly
strong Casual Conquest needs genuinely heavy ground to win in Group 1 company.
I'd also say that he's probably better over a mile and a half rather than ten
furlongs. This being so I wouldn't rate his chances of taking the Irish Champion
Stakes very highly at all.
This run did seem to suggest that CURTAIN CALL (40) is just
a shade below true Group 1 class. However it did confirm that Cumani's horse is
smart on soft ground.
Curtain Call's preference for softer ground is obscured by
a couple of races where the going was misreported. Race times show it was good
ground when he lost the Irish Derby and Grand Prix de Saint-Cloud not the
official good to yielding and soft. He'd won three of the four most recent times
that he'd run on genuinely yielding or softer ground before this good
performance and is capable of taking a Group 2 when he gets his ground.
If he were mine the race I'd be shooting for with Curtain
Call is the Premio Roma. The Italian race is invariably a weak Group 1 that's
almost always run on soft ground. Best of all it's over Curtain Call's optimum
trip of ten furlongs.
CLASHNACREE NEEDS LONGER
CLASHNACREE (36) clocked a pattern class time when losing a
hot six furlong maiden to Group placed Beethoven (36) at Leopardstown. He made
rapid progress and looked set to blow by Beethoven without any problem. But just
as he was about to do so the winner carried him across the track and managed to
hang on by a head. It was a little surprising that he didn’t lose the race in
the subsequent stewards’ enquiry.
Clashnacree is a bigger, scopier horse than Beethoven. He’s
built and bred for a mile or more. So it’s not surprising he ran below form
when cut back to five furlongs at Royal Ascot.
This was a very strongly run six furlongs and it clearly
brought Clashnacree’s obvious stamina into play. He will surely be stepped up
to seven furlongs next time and would deserve to be odds on for a maiden over
that trip. Indeed I rate him good enough to win an ordinary Group 3 over that
distance or a mile.
LILLIE LANGTRY NOT AS GOOD AS CABARET
Some bookies promoted LILLIE LANGTRY (34) to favourite for
the 1000 Guineas on the basis of her win in the Debutante Stakes. And while I
concede she ended up winning with a little in hand I can’t rate her in the
same league as her stablemate Cabaret on my ratings.
The way that Lillie Langtry outpaced DEVOTED TO YOU (32) in
the closing stages was impressive. But the runner up is a one-paced sort that’s
clearly going to be wanting much longer trips.
My prediction is that if Lillie Langtry represents Coolmore
in the Moyglare rather than Cabaret the prize will go to Godolphin courtesy of
Long Lashes.
DEVOTED TO YOU A SERIOUS OAKS PROSPECT
The best performance on the clock at Galway last week was
that put by DEVOTED TO YOU (37) in a seven furlong maiden. She bolted up by nine
lengths in a time that indicates she is a Group 1 filly.
In the race Devoted To You broke well but slowly ceded
ground despite being nudged along due to the searching early gallop. But then
they hit the uphill section approaching the straight and her stamina suddenly
came into play. She surged forward, soon took the lead and rolled further and
further ahead up the short homestraight.
On her debut Devoted To You had finished third to her top
class stablemate Cabaret in another seven furlong maiden where she stayed on
nicely in the closing stages. Next time out she clearly had problems being cut
back to six furlongs. She pushed on into the lead when asked to go and win the
race but simply lacked the pace to contain two rivals who went by her in the
final furlong. This time the combination of an extra furlong, heavy ground and a
very strong pace totally offset her obvious lack of acceleration.
Devoted To You is a tall, good-bodied, long striding, very
deep chested filly who looks built for every inch of a mile and a half. It's
tempting to say that she won't be fully effective at the relatively short
distances of two year old races in more normal, less testing circumstances. But
her improvement could also be due to simply getting fitter with each race. She's
a great big filly that has probably been hard to get fit at home.
We'll soon have the chance to see because Devoted To You is
engaged to run in the Group 2 Debutante Stakes as I write this. Whatever happens
to her there and in other big two year old races she looks a live prospect for
next year's Oaks.
ALFRED NOBEL PRODUCES DYNAMITE FINISH
As a producer of speed ratings I hate slow run races,
especially when they're as slow run as the Phoenix Stakes won by ALFRED NOBEL
(28). In this sort of situation even sectional times don't give me any sort of
handle on the winner's real level of ability.
However the opposition looked so good and the finishing
burst Alfred Nobel produced was so strong that I'm betting he'd have bested the
speed rating of 36 I gave him for his best previous performance if the early
pace had been stronger.
The way that Alfred Nobel picked up in the final furlong
was quite remarkable. He looked to be in an impossible position but gained
ground hand over fist to win full of running.
Seeing that he's built and bred for a mile and has already
won a strongly run seven furlong race I've no doubt Alfred Nobel will get the
Guineas trip. He's almost certainly a Group 1 horse. But we're going to have to
wait a while before the clock tells us that for sure.
CAPE BLANCO PROBABLY NEEDS LONGER
There is a powerful statistic in the Tyros Stakes. The last
ten winners have all had exactly one previous outing. Only fourteen horses with
one run to their name have contested the race in the last decade but they
produced all ten winners.
This year the obvious choice from the two Tryos Stakes
runners with one previous run was CAPE BLANCO (32) and he duly won. And he
looked impressive as he did so, particularly up the straight where he powered
away from his rivals.
Unfortunately there's no way I can interpret the final or
sectional times that Cape Blanco ran in the Tyros Stakes or on his winning debut
to say he's anything more than weak Listed class. This just doesn't feel right.
So my strong suspicion is that the reason he's looked good but hasn't run fast
is he's wanting longer. He's run really powerfully in the closing stages of both
his starts to date, getting stronger as his rivals have gotten weaker. And he
has the build of a middle distance runner to me.
I recognise that Cuis Ghaire and Nighttime have produced
their best over a mile. But all the other top fourty horses by Cape Blanco's
sire Galileo (as judged by Racing Post ratings) were best over ten furlongs
plus. You could argue that Cape Blanco's dam was a five furlong horse and
therefore counteracts this. But her best foal by far before Cape Blanco was Mr.
O'Brien who stayed on really strongly when second by half a length in the Grade
1 United Handicap over 1 mile and three furlongs in America. He was by
Mukaddamah, a much weaker influence for longer distances than Galileo.
This being so I don't think the 2000 Guineas is going to
prove the right long term target for Cape Blanco. Perhaps he'll do okay if
stepped up to a mile this year. But next year I reckon we'll be seeing him do
best over ten furlongs plus.
CABARET WORTH MAKING A SONG AND DANCE ABOUT
CABARET (38) put up quite some performance to win the Group
3 Silver Flash Stakes at Leopardstown. She set as strong pace right from the
start but actually managed to accelerate just after entering the straight to
clock a remarkably fast time. She came home 1.3 seconds faster over the last
three furlongs than the useful older horse Hard Rock City did over the same
distance in the preceding race and ran 0.84 seconds quicker for the full
distance.
There’s absolutely no question that this was a Group 1
performance on my speed ratings. In fact I doubt that we’ll see it bettered by
a two year old filly all season.
Cabaret was the fastest horse in the race on my speed
ratings and I was rather sure she could run faster than the Listed class time
she clocked on her previous start. On that occasion she was not fully ridden out
in the closing stages but still drew off nicely from a runner up that had made a
determined run at her. The way that she made two big moves in that race, the
first to kick on and the second to put away the runner up, is something only a
useful horse can do. And she did it with energy to spare. This being so I wasn’t
that surprised to see her make such a big move forward here.
On her debut Cabaret had run green when asked to pick up
around the home turn over this course and distance, dropping back instead of
picking up ground. However once her jockey decided to ride her out with hands
and heels only she moved up smoothly from fourth to second in the final furlong.
I have little doubt she’d have won if she’d known more about racing.
Cabaret is a muscular, rather classy looking filly that
looks set to be the top rated filly in the Free handicap at season’s end.
There’s a slight concern that she may need cut in the ground and a searching
gallop to be effective over seven furlongs and a mile. But she showed plenty of
pace here and doesn’t show any knee action. So I’m not concerned on that
score. I’d prefer to see her over a mile. But if she goes for the Moyglare
Stud Stakes over seven furlongs I’d still expect her to win even on fast
ground. She’s still a little leggy, so there’s plenty of reason for her to
improve from two to three. The 14-1 available about her for the 1000 Guineas
looks rather generous.
If there was another top class filly in the race I’d bet
on it being KITTY KIERNAN (33). She would almost certainly have been a clear
second instead of third if she hadn’t chased the winner so hard right from the
start.
Kitty Kiernan is a scopey, good-bodied, mature, good
looking sort that looks likely to improve on this run.
|