SIZING EUROPE COULD WELL IMPROVE OVER KEMPTON'S EASIER
FENCES
I've noted before that SIZING EUROPE (42) is a horse that
does not seem to like the idea of hitting a fence. He'll slow up to make sure
this doesn't happen.
Previously this hadn't caused him to lose too much ground.
But this wasn't the case in the Grade 1 JNWine.com Champion Chase at Down Royal.
He jumped the first safe and slow then really skyed the second, giving it masses
of room and losing several lengths. He didn't lost anything like that much
ground at the subsequent jumps but did cede a bit at several, notably the two
open ditches and five out.
It was tremendous that Sizing Europe could still move up to
challenge three out and look a major threat to go past Kauto Star. He couldn't
quite do it but made the Champion pull out all the stops for his four length
win.
I suspect it was the stiffness of Down Royal's fences as
much as Sizing Europe's inexperience that was the problem. I say this because
Down Royal's chase course has claimed a higher percentage of fallers than any
other in Britain or Ireland over the last fifteen years, barring the National
course at Aintree. 10.7% of the runners in chases at the track have fallen in
this period.
When Sizing Europe faces off against Kauto Star again in
the King George hw will be doing so over fences that have claimed only 6.6%
fallers over the last fifteen years. In fact so far this year just 6 of 210
chase runners at Kempton have fallen compared with 27 from 286 at Down Royal. So
the current difference in the stiffness of the fences looks to be a good deal
greater than the historical average.
Fences in Ireland claim a significantly higher percentage
of fallers than those in Britain. And it's worth remembering that the last time
Sizing Europe ran over fences in Britain he jumped perfectly despite being taken
along at a tremendous pace in a pretty big field in the Arkle over just two
miles. If he jumps as well as that in the King George he's going to be a serious
threat to Kauto Star and whatever else turns up. In this regard it's also worth
pointing out that the slow early pace at Down Royal probably gave Sizing Europe
way too much time to think about the first couple of jumps. The fence he cleared
with most proficiency was the last when he was fully extended.
Considering the slow early pace KAUTO STAR (43) put up a
seriously good performance on the clock, coming a good deal closer to my
standard time and that of the Racing Post than his smart stablemate The
Nightingale did in a truly run two and a half mile chase on the same card.
They went about six seconds a mile slower by estimates for
the first five furlongs than they would have done in a true run race. But they
picked up really well from there. If you time the video from landing over what
was the first jump in the two and a half mile race you'll find they got home
from there in 5m 2.3 seconds, which is 1.6 seconds quicker than The Nightingale
managed. In other words Kauto Star ran about three lengths a mile quicker.
This fact plus the past ratings earned by Sizing Europe and
third placed China Rock enable me to peg Kauto Star's run pretty accurately as
being worth 43 on my scale. That's a couple of lengths per mile off his lifetime
best but it's way more than we could reasonably expect after his last run in the
Gold Cup where he looked set to run unplaced for the first time in his chasing
career when falling five out.
If he can sustain this level of performance Kauto Star has
a real shot of winning his fifth King George. It should be noted though that he
had a harder race here than his connections were probably hoping for. He had a
battle royal with the second and third over the last half mile and won this on
sheer class and endurance. If he were mine I wouldn't think of giving him
another run between now and the King George. If he's to pull off the historic
five timer he's surely going to need to be rested.
Just how long Kauto Star can go on producing big runs like
this I don't know. He's already gone by many obvious statistical milestones
which normally suggest deterioration. My gut feel though is that the King George
may well be his final real shot at another Grade 1 win. I hope he proves me
wrong yet again because racing needs Champions like him to promote the sport to
a wider audience.
And let's be clear here. Whatever happens to Kauto Star
from now he has done more than enough to be recognised as the greatest
steeplechaser since Arkle.
CHINA ROCK (42) put up yet another big performance to come
home just half a length behind Sizing Europe in third. He's run fast on all
three of his starts this season, actually going a bit quicker each time
according to my ratings.
A feature of China Rock's performance here was his fast and
accurate jumping. He did breast five and six out but lost no ground.
Seeing that he's a bit below average size for a chaser I'm
going to be wary of supporting China Rock in really big fields. I also want to
see him prove he can win around a left-handed chase course seeing that he's run
unplaced all three times he's gone that way so far. Despite those provisos I'd
be surprised if China Rock didn't win a grade 1 chase this season. He's shown
that he can act on any ground and produce top class from two and a half to three
miles.
COOLCASHIN (26) managed to keep tabs on the leaders till
after five out when they started to get away from him. This is not that
surprising because although they clocked a fast final time for the overall
distance it was the last two and a quarter miles where the horses did all their
running in this race and Coolcashin is not a two and a quarter mile horse. His
strong suit is stamina not speed.
We've seen this sort of thing with Coolcashin before in the
Powers Gold Cup in April where Let Yourself Go took the field along at an
unsustainable pace for the two and a half miles in heavy ground. Let Yourself Go
tired badly and had to be pulled up but not before he'd forced several of his
rivals to get so tired they fell or had to pull up themselves. Among the pulled
up horses was Kempes, who won the Grade 1 Champion Novice Chase at Punchestown
next time, and Coolcashin. Given the furious gallop it's no surprise Coolcashin
got outpaced and had to be pulled up too.
Ideally I think Coolcashin needs an end to end gallop over
three miles plus.
Another highly important race in Coolcashin's record is the
Grade 2 at Navan in February where he jumped out to his right and got beat 46
lengths. In his subsequent starts Coolcashin has kept to right handed courses.
And his jockeys have deliberately steered him to the rail in all of them so that
he had no room to jump right at all (a common jockey tactic with horses that
jump this way). In this race he got a little crowded down the inside at a couple
of the early jumps and reacted by taking them too big.
Toss out the two runs where the pace was too fast and
you'll find that Coolcashin has won five of the other seven most recent times
he's gone right handed over trips of two and a half miles or more. One of his
losses was a most unlucky short head defeat by the smart Aranleigh where he
finished strong after being hampered. The other was last time out where he got
chopped for speed turning in but was staying on strongly to finish a length and
a half second to China Rock in a very fast run two and a half mile Grade 2. In
another 25 yards he would have won that race so strongly was he finishing.
With an official handicap mark of only 138 and a need to go
three miles plus in strongly run races around right handed tracks the obvious
targets for Coolcashin are the Thyestes Chase at Gowran Park in January then the
Irish Grand National. The King George would also suit him as it's invariably a
very strongly run race. The concern is he probably wouldn't be good enough to
win there but might well place judged by my speed ratings, and that would blow
his handicap mark for the Thyestes and Irish Grand National.
Coming up to the fifth last MOSSBANK (22) moved up to be
fifth by about four lengths, at which point he was going smoothly, just as well
as the eventual first, second and third. He tired from there, hit the fourth
last and finished far back. But this was a promising performance given the two
and a half year lay-off with leg problems that preceded it.
Mossbank has always gone well fresh in the past. In fact
he's won five times out of seven on his first two starts of the season before
this. But he surely needed this run, so I would not be at all surprised to see
him run a big race next time. The way he was traveling five out suggests he's
retained most if not all his ability.
TRAFFORD LAD was another top class horse returning
following leg problems. He collided with Sizing Europe landing over the first
and this may have got him a big too excited as he pulled quite hard from there.
He ended up tiring and jumping slow from soon after halfway before getting so
far back he was pulled up early in the straight. I'm not going to write him off
just yet though. He's a good looking Grade 1 winner that almost certainly needed
this run.
HIDDEN CYCLONE SOMETHING SPECIAL
HIDDEN CYCLONE (39) is a magnificent looking specimen. He's
good bodied, muscular and has the build to jump fences and stay at least two and
a half miles, quite possibly more. But he's also very athletic and clearly has
serious gears. He showed this when hosing up in the Grade 3 For Auction novice
hurdle at Navan.
It was evident approaching the straight that Hidden Cyclone
was cruising all over his rivals and he soon took the lead. He ran green and
jumped novicey when he was asked to go and win his race but still powered six
lengths clear after showing a really good turn of foot. He won with a fair bit
in hand and is obviously something special.
Hidden Cyclone is unbeaten after three starts, and he
looked so good here I imagine he'll start odds on for the two and a half mile
Grade 1 over the same course in a couple of weeks. I certainly wouldn't want to
be opposing him there.
If he's to go to Cheltenham I would like to see Hidden
Cyclone have as many runs as possible beforehand as he clearly still has a lot
to learn about the game. In fact if he were mine I'd be inclined to skip
Cheltenham altogether and concentrate on letting him learn the ropes in smaller
fields for the rest of this season. Next season he's going to be quite some
novice chaser.
OSANA SHOULD WIN NEXT TIME OVER TWO MILES
It was hard not to be taken with the comfortable success of
THE NIGHTINGALE (40) in the Grade 2 Ladbrokes.com Chase at Down Royal. If he
hadn't slipped up with the race won on one occasion he would now have won all
six times he's run around right handed courses. I'm counting Fontwell's figure
of eight chase track as right handed as the all important home turn is taken in
that direction.
The Nightingale, jumped well, was always traveling smoothly
and just lobbed along behind the leaders till going on three out. He only had to
be pushed out to score and it looked like he could have gone a bit quicker if he
had more competition.
Trainer Paul Nicholls told reporters afterwards that jockey
Ruby Walsh said it doesn't matter if The Nightingale goes left or right handed.
But Walsh rode The Nightingale like he was concerned he'd jump right if given
the chance by keeping him to the inside all the way around. And if the horse has
no problem going left-handed then how come he jumped so badly right at Aintree
and has lost all four times he's run that way, running well below form in his
three left handed tries over obstacles?
Until he proves he can show this same level of form on
left-handed courses I think it's safe to bet he's best right handed.
It also looks likely that the two and a half miles of the
Down Royal race is The Nightingale's right distance. He's a pacey sort that
looks built for this sort of distance. You could argue that his sire has
produced several good horses over three mile plus. But his dam won three sprints
on the flat and suffered her only loss in four hurdles starts the sole time she
ran beyond 1m 6f (they have hurdle races shorter than two miles in France).
This being so, The Nightingale's future campaign pretty
much writes itself as there are only five remaining Grade 1 or 2 chases he's
eligible for around two and a half miles. Of these, the sole Grade 1 is the
Ascot Chase in February which just has to be his big target.
The Nightingale's ability is rather too obvious for him to
offer any real betting value in the immediate future. For that I would look to
third placed OSANA (33) who clearly didn't stay the two and a half miles.
Osana was traveling just as well as The Nightingale till he
tired in the closing stages and surely needs to go back to two miles.
Like most good two milers Osana looks to be best on his
first two runs off a three month break then require resting for at least five
weeks to run well again. I think we can toss out his Champion Hurdle start where
he went off way too fast in first time blinkers. Otherwise Osana has won five of
the other seven most recent seven times he's been fresh over 2m 1f or less, with
one of his losses being a good second to Sizing Europe to whom he was giving six
pounds.
Osana can run seriously fast when fresh over shorter trips.
And he'll still be fresh next time as this was his seasonal debut. So I like his
chances of taking something very decent over two miles at a nice price next
time.
HAMPSHIRE EXPRESS A USEFUL NOVICE CHASER
Approaching the straight in the two mile novice chase at
Thurles last week HAMPSHIRE EXPRESS (38) looked to be in trouble on his chasing
debut. The pace seemed a little too quick for him as he was stretched into two
slow jumps and slipped back from second to fourth.
He still looked beat running up to the last but then picked
up suddenly as his stamina really kicked in, powered past the leaders and won
going away full of running.
Clearly the two miles was too short for Hampshire Express,
so it was tremendous that he could clock a Grade 3 class time. Over two and a
half miles, perhaps a bit more, he could well prove competitive in Grade 1
events. He's won three of his last four completed starts and is clearly
improving.
GLENCOVE MARINA STILL SMART ON SOFT GROUND
NOBLE PRINCE WINS RED HOT NOVICE CHASE
You can never really tell just how well a horse is going to
take to fences. So every few years you find one novice chase where a whole bunch
of horses improve for the switch to the bigger jumps and produce a red hot
contest.
This was undoubtedly the case with the Beginners Chase at
Punchestown won by NOBLE PRINCE (41) last week.
They came home from the first fence, just less than a
furlong after the start, 7.2 and 8.5 seconds quicker than they did in the two
chase over half a mile longer on the same card. Even when I adjust for the
shorter distance of Noble Prince's race that makes his time 2.4 seconds a mile
better than the next fastest chase. That's just enormous considering the next
fastest chase was won by a horse that earned a Racing Post rating of 143.
I've just got to go with what the clock says, and it says
this was a Grade 1 performance by Noble Prince.
Noble Prince just lobbed along in fifth place behind the
strong pace set by Bob Lingo and Saludos early on.
Despite the good early gallop the race developed into close
to a sprint from after three out but Noble Prince continued to move smoothly,
closing up easily to dispute the lead two out despite Saludos having just
swerved across him.
On the run in Noble Prince looked to have a fight on his
hands to catch Healys Bar who had his ears pricked and was full of run. But
Noble Prince just laughed at him, using his flat race speed to cruise by, barely
having to be ridden to do so.
Noble Prince was a good Group 2 horse on the flat and
around Grade 2 class over hurdles. But this run says he's absolutely top class
over fences.
I loved the way that Noble Prince jumped like an old hand
here and wasn't at all put off when Saludos got stretched into nearly slithering
to the ground in front of him two out. And I was most impressed with the turn of
foot he showed. Very few chasers can quicken up the way he did in a race where
they'd already accelerated. As far as I'm concerned I've found my ante-post bet
for the Arkle. At 33-1 the bookies have gone way too big with this one in my
opinion. Later this month in the Grade 2 Craddockstown Novices Chase over the
same course and distance I think he'll show just how good he is and plummet in
price for the big Cheltenham race.
HEALYS BAR (40) is a bigger, more traditional national hunt
sort with less pace than the winner. He sat close to the pace and worked his way
forward to dispute the lead two out and had the lead on the run in when moving
really well. He couldn't match the winner who just swamped him for finishing
speed but put up a tremendous performance for a chasing debutante.
Healys Bar ran third in a two and a half mile Grade 1 over
hurdles and a decent third in a good three mile race. He certainly should stay
just as far over the bigger jumps but clearly has the ability to win some of the
top novice chases over two miles.
BOB LINGO (39) did really well to rally after being headed
three out but couldn't quite go with the first two from the last. Nonetheless
this was also a tremendous performance by a novice. he's very lightly raced for
an 8YO and looks a very good two mile chaser in the making.
Fourth placed SALUDOS (36) disputed the lead at a strong
pace but got stretched into a bad error two out when the race developed into a
near sprint. He slithered on landing, very nearly came down and lost a lot of
momentum. He did well to pick up again and stay on quite nicely though outpaced
from there.
Saludos has a really long stride and his three wins have
all been on heavy ground. I just don't think he has the pace to produce his best
on such a quick surface and that's why he got stretched into that jumping error.
When he encounters softer ground I'll be very interested in his chances. In
addition, despite the fact he seemingly failed to get home in his two tries
beyond two miles I can't believe that a horse built like him won't stay longer
distances.