|
ORANGE TOUCH RUNS A GROUP 1 TIME
Yikes, how good is Orange Touch? He dotted up by six lengths
the first time he stepped up to a trip beyond ten furlongs at Newmarket. Now
he's gone and romped the March Stakes at Goodwood by no less than eleven lengths
from a very strong field.
Orange Touch is German bred, and German horses invariably stay
a whole lot better than those bred elsewhere. So you could argue that on soft
ground at a mile and three quarters he was the only runner that really got the
trip. But whatever the reason, the clock says this was a huge run by Orange
Touch.
Johnny Murtagh rode Orange Touch and trainer Amanda Perrett
said that he told her to run the horse in the Irish Leger as soon as he
dismounted in the winner's circle. She reportedly said that might be a bit too
ambitious but my speed figures say she ought to listen to Murtagh. If Orange
Touch runs in the Irish Leger I would not want to oppose him.
Orange Touch has posted his two impressive wins on soft
ground. But I think it's almost certainly the longer distance rather than the
ground that's wrought the improvement. His breeder apparently warned against
running him on anything but fast ground. That's hardly surprising seeing he's by
Lando, who hated even a tiny drop of moisture in the ground. I reckon Orange
Touch will be able to reproduce this form on a firm surface. The intriguing
question is whether or not he'll be able to reproduce it over two furlongs
shorter. If he can then races like the Arc, the King George and the Breeders'
Cup Turf should be logical targets for him next season. If he turns out to be a
stayer then the Melbourne Cup looks a very interesting proposition. Right now,
if I were Amanda Perrett I'd be entering Orange Touch for the Irish Leger, the
Breeders' Cup, the Canadian International, the Japan Cup and the Hong Kong Vase.
My ratings say he's that good.
CHIC (42) also ran a big time when taking the Celelbration
Mile on the same card. She ran as fast as most Group 1 winners have this term
and has clearly improved. It could be that the slower ground has helped her. It
may also be that she's best on straight courses or small fields like this seeing
how often she's hit traffic problems in bigger fields around a turn. In any
event, the Sun Chariot stakes looks to offer Chic a great opportunity to score
her first Group 1 win.
Over at Newmarket on the same day BORDER CASTLE (39) posted a
solid Group class time to beat the useful ZERO TOLERANCE (37) at Newmarket. The
amazing thing is that this was the three year old's first run of the year. No
doubt Border Castle will be running in Group company soon enough. Right now he
can still get into handicaps, so trainer Sir Michael Soute must surely be
thinking of taking down a big prize with Border Castle soon. I note with
interest that he has the horse entered up in the valuable John Smith's stakes at
Newbury on September 18th. The weights are already out for that race and Border
Castle has been rated on his old form and assigned bottom weight of 7-8. The
danger now of course is that he'll miss the cut. But if he makes the line up
that race is surely at his mercy.
ANCIENT WORLD (42) ran a huge race to beat the very smart
Gateman at Windsor. I don't know why he ran so poorly at Salisbury on his
previous start. It could well be that race came too soon after his big Goodwood
win. His connections put the sticky ground at Salisbury down as the reason for
his loss. But it was the same going at Windsor by my estimates. In any event,
Ancient World ran a Group 1 time here and is clearly a very useful horse. Races
like the Eclipse and Juddmonte International next season look like logical
targets. This season I'd like to see him given a shot at Group 1 company over
ten furlongs.
POSTERITAS (37) won a Listed race at Yarmouth and could well
be a decent filly. She's now won two of the three times she's gone a middle
distance. Her only loss came in a fantastically hot race behind INTO THE DARK at
Newmarket. The winner earned a Group 3 speed figure from me in that race and the
form has worked out incredibly well. In fact, if Lost Soldier Three hadn't been
squeezed for room on his next outing and lost narrowly, the first four home
would have won all five of their subsequent starts. Into The Dark, I note with
interest, is entered in the St Leger. It's also interesting to note that Into
The Dark is the only Leger entry that passes the five stamina points test I use
to identify likely winners of the final classic - a test that 28 of the last 34
Leger winners have passed.
Gerard Butler doesn't often miss when he runs a two year old
in a Scottish maiden race, and he took his record up to 9 wins from 18 with
CYCLICAL (33) at Hamilton the other day.
Cyclical ran a rating only four lengths a mile off the fastest
I've awarded to a juvenile so far this year despite getting off to a slow start
and winning with what seemed to be something in hand. It looks likely therefore
that he is capable of improvement. The race I'd be shooting for if I owned him
would be the Flying Childers at Doncaster's Leger meeting. He'd have a real
chance in that Group 2 race, and if he's kept below Group class next time I'd
rate him a good thing.
YAJBILL (31) is another two year old that looks worth
following. He showed seriously improved form according to my speed ratings to
take a Birghton maiden. Birghton maidens are normally weak and Yajbill has
already earned an official rating of 81. So I'm betting that the handicapper is
going to use that as a guide. This will mean Yajbill will be eligible for an
ordinary nursery handicap where he'd make a pretty decent bet.
Runner-up OLIGARCH (31) looks even more interesting. He's bred
to go further than the six furlongs of this race and finished strongly to go
under by just a neck. This was his racecourse debut and my studies show horses
invariably improve at least three points on my ratings for their debut. That
makes Oligarch look like a potential pattern winner like his half brother who
won the Soalrio stakes. He looks like a good thing to win a maiden next time out
even if he sticks to six furlongs. At seven he'd be even more interesting.
The fastest two year old time of the past week was put up by
Chic's half sister ECHELON (34) who won on her racecourse debut at Newmarket. My
ratings say Echelon ran a Group 3 time here. Most horses improve a good deal on
their debut run, so the top fillies races all look logical targets for Echelon
now.
Runner-up NEWSROUND (31) was also making his racecourse debut
and ran a time that would win plenty of Listed races. He'll surely be odds-on if
he sticks to maiden company next time. But he might well be a betting
proposition in a Listed or Group race.
Our old friend COLEORTON DANCER (32) is another juvenile who
earned a pattern class speed rating from me on the same card. He took the
nursery, validating the indications from his pedigree that a softer surface and
a longer trip than five furlongs would suit him. Coleorton Dancer has run a bit
quicker than this previously and is well capable of taking a Group race. So
MARCHING SONG (31) did well to get to within half a length of him.
Marching Song is a typical Richard Hannon two year old in that
he's improved for racing -something confirmed by his jockey, who said that he's
only just coming to himself. With normal racing luck he should be capable of
taking one of the more valuable nurseries or perhaps a Listed race.
There are a whole mess of fast sprinters in Britain, so I'm
always wary of nominating one as a horse to follow. Nonetheless SPANISH ACE (38)
ran so fast in such a low grade race that I just have to put him forward. His
trainer, Andrew Balding, says he bounced back to form because of a hood and ear
plugs being applied. I suspect the small field helped more though. After all,
why was Spanish Ace bothered by the noise of other runners in the first place.
Fear of crowding is surely the answer. In this regard it's interesting to note
that Spanish Ace has reached the first two four times out of five at less than
seven furlongs in what my research says counts as a small field (11 runners or
less) but has not reached the first four in seven tries in bigger fields.
Therefore I'd like to see Spanish Ace go for another conditions race next time.
In a handicap I'd bet on claustrophobia beating him.
Runner-up DEVISE (38) was unlucky to come up against a revived
Smokin Beau in his last two starts. He was unlucky once more to encounter a
horse unusually fast for the class here and went down narrowly for the third
time in a row. He's in such form that surely he'll find a race soon - especially
seeing that he seems able to run his race on any track or going as long as the
trip is five furlongs.
At a much longer distance SENDINTANK (36) showed that he's
tough to get by on a slow surface when winning at Newmarket. This was the sixth
time he's won in six tries on Fibresand or soft or heavy turf at 12 furlongs or
more. He's almost certainly capable of going a bit faster, so I'd be wary of
opposing him in any sort of race if the current wet weather holds and the ground
stays soft.
DIKTATORIAL EQUALS FASTEST 2YO TIME
How good is DIKTATORIAL (37)? he ran away with a Sandown
maiden over seven furlongs, equaling the biggest rating I've given a two year
old all season in Europe. He did this despite hanging all over the place. With
more experience he should learn to run straighter and faster.
I don't know what plans are in store for Diktatorial. But I'd
expect to see him win a Group 1 race in the next month or two.
SURAWAKI (31) and GLEN IDA (31) were beaten a long way into
second and third. But I'd expect to see them franking this form by winning
maiden races next time out as they both ran quicker than the average maiden
winner.
Another Group class time by a two year old was that recorded
by CUPID'S GLORY (35) at Chester. He won by a pretty big margin, just as he had
on the Polytrack last time. His pedigree says he ought to improve over seven
furlongs (this was six). I can see him winning something like the Horris Hill
stakes at Newbury and suspect his trainer, Sir Mark Prescott, is going to have
to revise his apparent plan to win the string of minor races that he's currently
entered for.
Windsor Knot (36) earned a speed rating well up to the Group 3
standard of the Solario stakes. But, as Diktatorial showed, there are a lot of
fast juveniles which have yet to tackle Group company yet. So things are going
to get a lot tougher for Windsor Knot from now on. Fast as he is, I therefore
can't quite recommend following him.
Sometimes a slow time can tell you as much about a race as a
fast time. This is probably the case with the first day of the big York meeting
held recently. The jockeys at this meeting who were interviewed early on all
seemed to believe that the going was soft when my going allowance showed that it
was actually good to firm. The jockeys rode to their belief and had their mounts
go an early pace that would have been correct on soft ground but was way too
slow on good to firm. They only seemed to learn the error of their ways after
the first four races, since the times of the remaining contests indicated they
were truly run throughout.
The chief sufferer of the slow early pace in the Juddmonte
International was almost certainly BAGO (29). Bago had shown last time out that
he could get caught flat-footed in a slow run race by a rival with instant
acceleration. His old rival Cacique was able to open up a four length break on
him which he only closed down very late. Here a similar thing seemed to occur.
Bago was scrubbed along when the pace quickened and only got rolling too late.
You could argue that the way Bago has run in his last two
races suggests that the original plan to run him in mile and a half races was
correct and that ten furlongs is a bit short for him. Another equally valid view
is that he's basically running like a dirt horse on grass. The top dirt horses
do not have instant acceleration. Like Bago, they can produce a prolonged surge
which takes a while to build up to. In a slow run turf race they can get caught
out as Bago was here. In this regard it's interesting to note that there are a
whole mess of dirt runners on Bago's dam's side while his sire Nashwan produced
Swain who narrowly lost the world's two most valuable dirt races - the Dubai
World Cup and the Breeder's Cup Classic.
The problem for Bago is that every jockey now knows how to
beat him on turf. They simply have to set a slow pace and then kick. For this
reason, if he were mine, I'd forget about the Irish Champion stakes and run him
instead in the Jockey Club Gold Cup on dirt at Belmont Park in New York. Then
again, Godolphin have a habit of putting in a pacemaker, and with their Irish
Champion stakes runner Doyen cutting back to ten furlongs they will surely want
to ensure a strong pace at Leopardstown which would of course help Bago
tremendously.
In any event, it all goes to show that no horse is unbeatable.
Secretariat got beat, Nijinsky got beat, Mill Reef got beat. And now Bago has
got beat. I still believe that Bago may well be one of the best horses we've
seen in years. He's done some extraordinary things in his races - earning the
fastest speed figure I awarded a juvenile last season, the biggest speed ratings
I've awarded any horse this year and running an astonishing 21.7 seconds for the
last quarter mile last time out (the fastest final two furlongs I've ever heard
of). Okay, we now know Bago has an Achilles heel that smart jockeys can exploit.
But his connections now know it too.
The only time worth noting from the first two days of the York
meeting was that run by ENCHANTMENT (38) who I've mentioned here before.
Enchantment again showed she is pattern class by running away with a good sprint
handicap. I don't know where she goes from here, but Enchantment still looks
worth following.
The next day Bahamian Pirate (41) beat the same old band of
regulars that have been infesting the top sprints this season. He earned a speed
rating that several handicappers have beaten this term in sprints, so I can't
recommend following him or any of those he beat.
MERCHANT (32) romped a York nursery by seven lengths in Listed
class time. We've been seeing some unusually fast times in nurseries this season
(e.g. Coleorton Dancer and Nova Tor). I don't quite know why. I suspect Britain
is moving closer to the situation in Ireland where nurseries have been better
contested than in Britain in the past. Over there it's not unusual to see
pattern class horses run in handicaps at two. It looks like the British
nurseries are following suit. This makes sense, as my research says early season
three year old handicaps in Britain have steadily been attracting more pattern class
runners in recent years. In any event Merchant looks likely to win again pretty
soon.
TOPKAMP (37) obviously appreciated the step up to a mile and a
half when winning a Salisbury handicap in fast time. This David Elsworth trained
three year old is by the good hurdles sire Simply Great. Seeing that Elsworth
usually has a decent juvenile hurdler, it would be very interesting to see this
over timber where he might well develop into a Triumph hurdle candidate.
However, it appears that his major objective is next year's Ebor. He showed that
he has the talent for that sort of race her, running a Listed class time, and
looks likely to win again soon. In fact, it looks like he'll still be eligible
for class D handicaps after this run. At that level I can't see him getting
beat.
Runner-up CIRCASSIAN (36) was another maiden stepping up in
distance in handicap company. Sir Mark Prescott frequently scores with this maneuver
but Circassian bumped up against a very smart opponent in Topkamp here. I note
with interest that Sir Mark has the horse entered in a whole bunch of upcoming
handicaps. Clearly he intends to exploit Ciurcassian's current ludicrously low
official handicap mark. I can see him placing Circassian to win several races in
a row.
On the same day Norton (38) won a hot class C handicap at
Sandown. He'll be forced to tackle better company after this so is probably not
worth following. Runner-up LITERATIM (37) looks the horse to take out of the
race. This Cumani-trained four year old has only had four runs and stayed on
well to get to within three parts of a length of Norton. He could be anything
and ran fast enough here to win in higher class.
At Chester ZONUS (38) continued the season's big theme of
pattern class times by three year olds in handicaps. He sluiced up by five
lengths from a smart field of older horses. His jockey put the improvement down
more to the soft ground than the first time blinkers, and looking at the horse's
pedigree, that would seem to be the most probable explanation. Certainly Zonus
should be able to win again soon if the going stays squidgy.
TAKE THE STAND IS ONE OF THE TOP CHASERS
There has been a significant increase in the number of
valuable Summer jumps races staged in recent years. One of them, the Lord
Mildmay Memorial Chase at Newton Abbot, attracted a seriously strong field. It
was routed by TAKE THE STAND (43) who put up a huge performance, earning a Gold
Cup class speed rating from me.
Take The Stand's form seems to be dictated by a recurring back
problem. Chasers really have to bend their backs when they jump fences and a
high percentage of them suffer from back problems as a result. The only thing
that helps is rest in between their races. If they're not given a break of six
weeks plus their backs normally haven't had time to recover from the last chase
and they jump poorly as a result. This appears to have happened to Take The
Stand a few times. But he's now won all five times he's run over fences when
he's come into the race six or more weeks after his last completed chase start.
Take The Stand's next target is apparently the Hennessy Gold
Cup at Newbury in November. If he's kept fresh for that race I wouldn't want to
oppose him.
At the same meeting MARCEL (37) maintained his unbeaten UK
record when running away with a novice hurdle. He's now looking a good deal
better than an early season sort, so I suspect Pipe will put him away till the
bigger prizes for novice hurdlers start appearing in October. If he's kept on
the go he should extend his winning sequence.
PRINCESSE GREC (37) added to to number of unusually smart
novice chasers we've seen in the off season when taking a handicap chase at
Worcester in fast time. But for a couple of narrow losses Princesse Grec would
be unbeaten in six starts this year. She ran off a mark of just 88 here and
looks ludicrously well handicapped despite all her wins. For this reason she
will no doubt be kept to handicaps for the immediate future where I'd be wary of
opposing her.
LUCKY STORY IS BACK
The Sovereign Stakes at Salisbury only had a Group 3 grading
from the pattern committee but it was good as most of the Group 1's for older
horses that we've seen this year. NORSE DANCER (42) won the race, validating the
idea that he's at his best on 'switchback' tracks like Epsom, Goodwood and
Salisbury.
Norse Dancer is now being aimed at a quick return in the
Juddmonte International. I hope he starts there because I'd like to see another
loss in his record to build the odds for when he returns to another switchback
track, Goodwood, for the Celebration Mile on August 28th.
Norse Dancer is good enough to take an ordinary Group 1, and
he needs to in order to be sold for a decent sum as a stallion. So I suspect
we'll be seeing him again next year for another shot at the Sussex stakes. That
seems the race most likely to earn him the Group 1 win he needs. He's gone close
in the last two running's and must have a real shot of making it third time
lucky in 2005.
LUCKY STORY (42) ran a huge race off an eleven month break to
go under by a mere short head. His trainer and jockey are convinced he will come
on for the run. That means he's going to be one tough horse to beat in the QEII
next time out.
HURICANE ALAN (40) ran his usual sort of big rating to finish
third. As is normal for him in a big field, he had to be switched when making
his run. I remain convinced that he is pretty much unbeatable in a very small
field (i.e. seven runners or less) and that he might well spring a major shock
in a Group 1 where the field cut up.
PASSING GLANCE (40) like the winner seems to love switchback
tracks. He's run a tad quicker, and might have just needed the run - since he'd
been off for nearly two months before his next to last start. He's just been
sold to the National Stud. So his last remaining shot at Group race glory comes
in the Celebration Mile as well. Then again, the National Stud have been known
to keep a horse like this in training. That might be a smart move with Passing
Glance because he's good enough to take a Group 1 and that would boost his
popularity at stud immeasurably.
I confess that I am not fond of sprinters. But I have to make
note of SMOKIN BEAU (42) who bounced back to his very best to run away with the
prestigious Great St Wilfred handicap at Ripon. He's looking rather interesting
for the Ayr Gold Cup now which is apparently his target. A Group race would be
well within his compass on this form. I can see him winning the Prix Abbaye at a
monster price for example.
An old sprinter that's already won the Abbaye is CONTINENT
(42) who roared right back to his best to take a hot conditions sprint at
Nottingham. I may be over-interpreting his form here, but it seems to me he's
needed good or softer ground these past three seasons and is at his best from
mid July onwards. He's won four of his last five starts in these circumstances
and looks to have a real chance of winning the Abbaye again on this run -
especially if the ground has a bit of cut in it on the big day. It's a shame
Continent wasn't in the Nunthorpe a few days after this run. He would have had a
real chance.
At as somewhat lower level, WUNDERBRA (36) looks to be a
sprinter worth following. She won in unusually good time for a low grade
handicap at Windsor and is capable of winning in slightly better company
according to my ratings. She's won two of her three starts and run close in the
other since switching back to turf.
Runner-up SKYHARBOR (36) showed improved form on his first run
for his new stable. He'd be something of a good thing for a class D handicap
sprint next time on this run.
The fastest two year old colt according to my speed ratings is
Afrashad who started his career on the Polytrack. Now SUMORA (36) another
Polytrack debutante has gone and earned the biggest speed figure I've awarded a
juvenile filly to take a very warm Listed race at Newbury.
Sumora's next target apparently is the Flying Childers at
Doncaster. She'll be tough to beat there.
NOTJUSTAPRETTYFACE (32) ran a good race to finish fourth
following a two month break. She ran a bit quicker on her debut and may well
have needed this. Looking at her pedigree it looks likely she'll improve for a
longer trip as well. She remains an interesting prospect for the Chevelely Park
stakes.
NOVA TOR (33) is another two year old filly worth noting. She
ran a solid pattern class time to take a Newmarket nursery. It could well be
that she only just gets the minimum distance. So I'm a bit concerned that her
next entry is at Sandown, seeing how she failed to get the five furlongs at
Beverley which has an uphill finish like the Esher course. That said, it's tough
to interpret the form of a lightly raced horse. All I can really say is that
Nova Tor is very fast and ought to be followed.
The two year old colts produced a pattern race candidate
recently as well in COLEORTON DANCER (35) who won a Nottingham nursery by a wide
margin. He'd won in a similar style on his on his previous start, after which
his trainer had this to say; "We gelded him after his last run, and that
seems to have made the difference. He was a maniac in the paddock at Chester
last time, and in his races he was the sort of horse who wanted to do everything
too quickly. He settled much better there and won like a decent horse."
Coleorton Dancer highlights one of the problems of the
handicap system. The handicapper can only rate a horse on what it has beaten.
So, if by happenstance it runs a string of moderate races and then its connections
discover why, it can end up in cheap races such as those Coleorton Dancer has
been contesting. In this instance, it looks likely that if Coleorton Dacner
sticks to handicap company it will be several runs yet before his official
ratings reflects something like his true ability. I'd say he's set to win again,
whatever type of race he contests next time. He's won both times very easily
since being gelded and is Group class according to my ratings.
CHIC (40) won the Hungerford stakes in decent time. She's
clearly very well suited by the seven furlongs of the race. So the Prix Foret
looks a logical target, seeing how that race is so often a very soft Group 1.
NEW MORNING (40) has run well against some of the top fillies
at 11 and 12 furlongs this season. But she clearly improved on my numbers for
the cut back to ten when winning a strong Listed race at Salisbury. Michael
Jarvis says he's now convinced she is a better horse over ten furlongs just like
her half sister, Islington, and that seems clear from her speed figures. Her
next target apparently is the Blandford stakes at the Curragh. There are a lot
of smart fillies around this year, but she ought to be hard to beat there. She
showed herself to be one of the top three year old fillies here. Top fillies
like Ouija Board, Lune D'Or and Latice have only earned one point bigger
ratings.
TAHTHEEB (39) was unlucky to come up against such a smart
opponent in a mere LIsted race and ran well to finish a good second. She ought
to be able to win a Listed race herself with ease and is well up to Group
standard on my ratings.
SNOW GOOSE (37) was my idea of the winner following her smart
run against another top pair last time. She ran fast again here and I like the
run from a betting point of view because on a bare read of her form she doesn't
look that impressive, having lost six in a row and never scored in pattern
company. This means she could well start at tempting odds in pattern company
next time. She'd win most Listed races easily, so I'd love to see her at the
same level next time.
JEEPSTAR (38) did zip in his first few starts last year but
then hit a rich vein of form while earning pattern class speed figures. The same
pattern seems to be developing in his form this year, as evidenced by his recent
win in a time between Listed and Group 3 class at Pontefract where he beat the
German Listed winner Pretty Star into second. Trainer Tim Easterby beleives
Jeepstar will make a useful novice hurdler which is probably true. Equally true
is that he's so insanely well handicapped that Easterby's been able to enter him
for a class D handicap at Ripon in a few days time. I suspect Jeepstar is going
to win a few more times before he's done for the season, and I'd like to see him
shoot for the November handicap.
CAPABLE GUEST (34) had to cope with short distances and slow
run races in his previous starts. But he showed what he could do in a strongly
run race over seven furlongs when winning a maiden in good time at Leicester.
His next target is apparently the Prix Dufont D'Eelevage at Deauville. He should
have a great shot of winning that. Though I'd have to add a note of caution.
He's got an edge on the French juveniles we've seen so far. But the top French
two year olds do tend to start appearing at the big meeting on the Cote D'Azure.
Second and third PIANOFORTE (32) and BANCHIERI (32) shouldn't
have any problems winning their maidens next time out. Both are probably pattern
class.
GIOCOSO (36) earned an unusually big speed rating for a class
D handicap when scoring at Leicester. His trainer now thinks he's best at a mile
and that it was a mistake to ruin him over longer distances. He's now won both
times he's had a recent race and run over what seems to be his optimum distance,
so it's tough to say just how good he is. Certainly he ought to be good enough
to follow up this win if he's entered in a class C or D contest over a mile
again soon.
TROJAN FLIGHT (36) also ran fast in a class D handicap and has
clearly improved massively since cut back to five furlongs. He should be able to
win again soon over the minimum distance and may well be capable of running a
bit faster.
Another big speed figure in a race where you don't normally
find them was the good rating earned by TENDER FALCON (37) when he ran away with
a Bath amateur rider's race. Tender Falcon has clearly improved since being
stepped up to a mile and a half. In fact, but for getting pipped on the post by
the smart Party Ploy he would have won three of the four times he's raced this
far. He looks capable of winning in better company.
Over jumps MINBULE (36) ran an enormous speed figure for a
selling hurdle when running away with a Newton Abbot race by 16 lengths. I'm not
surprised Martin Pipe's stable bought the horse in at the post-race auction. Off
his low official handicap mark Minibule looks set to win a string of low grade
races at 'gaff' tracks. I rather doubt Pipe would risk losing him in a seller or
claimer again.
MISTER MONEY RUNS A GROUP 1 TIME
The Group 3 Rose of Lancaster stakes normally attracts a field
that is much stronger than its official grading. This was true again this year.
I thought the two key protagonists were Muqbil, who'd won the four previous
times he'd run on dead flat courses like Haydock, and Checkit, who has
consistently shown he can run with Group 1 horses in small fields. But these two
smart older performers were brushed aside by the three year old MISTER MONET
(42).
I think you can toss out Mister Monet's racecourse debut as it
was over only six furlongs. You can also throw out his seasonal debut this year,
as it was his first start in a year following a major injury. He's won all his
other four starts impressively and just keeps running quicker and quicker.
Mark Johnston is apparently thinking of cutting back Mister
Monet to a mile for the QEII. There are two reasons not to do that. The first is
that Mister Monet showed signs of inexperience here - looking at the crowd and
wandering when in front. This suggests he needs a bit more 'seasoning' before
taking on Group 1 runners. The second reason not to go for the QEII is that it's
over two furlongs less than his big Haydock win. I have a maxim; 'a horse is at
its most effective at the outermost limits of its stamina'. At trips short of
its best a horse will need a furious early pace to be effective, while at
distances beyond its optimum it will need a slow early pace to last home.
Clearly Mister Monet stays at least ten furlongs. He might well go a mile and a
half judged on his pedigree.
In any event, wherever Mister Monet goes next I'd think long
and hard about opposing him. This run showed that he is one of the best three
year olds in Europe. Even in the QEII, despite my concerns, he'd be a bit
interesting since that race is invariably very fast run and normally goes to a
horse which stays ten furlongs.
At the same meeting DUNAKSIN (38) sprang a 50-1 surprise to
take the valuable Totesport stakes, a big handicap. My read of Dunaskin's form
is that he's a ten furlong specialist that is only effective at a mile on soft
ground and needs a recent race (15 days or less). In the circumstances I've just
described he's now won five times out of seven and gone close in his two losses.
If he's turned out again soon over ten furlongs I can see him winning again.
PENTECOST (42) demonstrated once more that is is among the top
milers in Europe by winning the Shergar Cup Mile in terrific time.
Previously he'd run a seriously good Group 2 time to win one
of Europe's biggest handicaps last time. On tracks with uphill finishes like
this he has a terrific record at a a mile - as long as he's had a race in the
last three weeks. With a bit of racing luck he probably would have won the last
six time times he's run in these circumstances but for a slow start and
subsequent traffic problems one one occasion and an effort that was probably
delayed too long in a fast-finishing loss in a Group 3.
Petnecost now goes for the European Mile Championship, the
QEII over what is clearly his favorite course and distance - Ascot's mile. I'd
be surprised if he failed to reach the placing in that race, and he might just
win it.
Runner up VORTEX (41) equaled his best lifetime speed rating
to chase Pentecost home. He is a seriously smart horse and ought to be racing in
Group company. In fact, in my opinion, he oughtn't to be racing in Europe at
all. He belongs in America on dirt where he could rack up as much money as he's
earned in his entire life with a single win in a decent Grade 2. Vortex lacks
the acceleration normally required to win big races on turf. On dirt, it's a
different ball game.
WING COMMANDER (40) ran his best ever race to finish third. It
may well be that he's best in smallish fields like this, so I'd like to see him
switched to pattern company. He'd be a solid bet to take a Group 3 and a near
certainty in Listed company.
Fourth placed COLISAY (39) earned a Group class speed figure
for the fifth time in his last seven races. He's still a fresh horse, having had
just three runs this year, and he acts on the kind of soft ground that tends to
prevail in the Autumn. So I'd bet on him winning something big between now and
the end of the year. I'd like to see him in a Group 3 or a Listed race. But he'd
also be interesting in another valuable handicap.
At the same meeting PARADISE ISLE (39) won the Shergar Cup
sprint in seriously good time. I confess I'm only taking a stab at the standard
time for the distance of his race, as this meeting was the first where they've
had to run six furlong races on the round course at Ascot. But I based her
rating on the standard time for the straight course, and the round six must be
at least as slow since the uphill start is steeper according to the course map
and they have to negotiate a turn which adds about 0.6 of a second to the time.
Paradise Isle has now won the last three times she's run a
very stiff five furlongs or gone six. She beat a seriously good field here and
is clearly a smart filly who appreciated the step up in distance here. She
deserves a shot at pattern company and would be a good bet to take a Listed
sprint against her own sex. She might well stay seven furlongs too.
JUSTAQUESTION (33) won the Shergar Cup Juvenile in decent
time. She started off in the Brocklesby but clearly appreciates a better test of
stamina than that race provided. With luck in running she would have won all
five times she's raced on yielding or softer ground or at seven furlongs plus.
She must have a decent chance in the Group 3 Prestige stakes at Goodwood which
is her next target. I'd say Justaquestion ought to improve again at a mile, so
she might well end up having a good shot in the Fillies' Mile back at Ascot.
Runner-up BEAVER PATROL (33) also looks a good bet to improve
at a mile seeing how much he improved when stepped up to seven furlongs here.
His speed rating only ranks as Listed class, but not many two year olds run as
fast as he did here at seven furlongs plus. So I can see him winning a Listed or
Group 3 contest.
LAMH EILE (33) completed the three way photo to take third.
She lost for the first time in three starts here but ran fast enough to suggest
she's worth a shot at a Group 3. She and the winner ran a tad faster than Maids
Causeway (32) who took the Group 3 Sweet Solera on the same day at Newmarket.
But, as I've mentioned before, the Group races for two year olds seen so far
have been unusually weak. For some reason the better juveniles seem to have been
hanging back in maidens and conditions races or not even racing a bit longer
than usual.
If Henry Candy trained the tortoise in that mythical contest
with the hare my money would be on the tortoise. Candy has an extraordinary
knack of getting horses to sprint. He's the mirror image of Mark Johnston who
seems to know how to get horses to stay. One of these days I hope some academic
studies the methods of these two trainers. They'd probably uncover something
very useful about training a horse to run a specific distance.
I mention this because Candy has gone and done it again with
RUM SHOT (38). This three year old put up a Group class time when winning a warm
Listed sprint against older horses at Chester. Rum Shot won well and seemed to
have a bit in had, so it's hard to tell how much faster he can run. But I'd bet
Candy is right when he says "he ought to go for a Group race" as he
did in the winner's enclosure.
The top fillies are a pretty hot bunch this year. The expanded
programme of fillies pattern races has clearly persuaded the owners of many
smart females to keep them in training at four and up this term. SAHOOL (39) is
only three but she managed to beat older fillies and mares in what turned out to
be a rather warm Chalice stakes at Newbury. Sahool has steadily improved this
year and deserves a shot at the Yorkshire Oaks or Prix Vermeille on this run.
She's probably not quite good enough but wouldn't have to improve much more to
have a real chance in either contest. More likely, seeing that her trainer says
she stays so well, Sahool will end up in the Park Hill stakes at Doncaster.
She'd be tough to beat there.
POLAR JEM (39) improved significantly over the extra distance
to run Sahool to a neck. She'd won five of the previous six times she'd run
beyond a mile on fast ground and finished a good sixth in the John Smiths Magnet
Cup in one of her two losses. I'm rather hoping that the handicapper doesn't
refer to the time of this race and leaves Polar Jem on her current mark of 92.
That would give her a major chance of winning a big handicap like the one at
Ascot at the end of September. Of course, Polar Jem is a filly, and that means
her owners will be keen to get her Group placed. From a betting point of view
I'm rather hoping she takes up her engagement in the Group 3 Rose Of Lancaster
stakes. That race is run over only ten furlongs and would pitch her in against
colts. So it's unlikely that she'd run well. The punters would most likely put
this big run at Newbury down as a fluke and allow her to start at nice odds when
she steps back up to twelve furlongs.
SELEBELA (38), like the winner, keeps on improving. The way
she got outpaced then stayed on again strongly at the finish suggests that she
ought to be joining the winner in the Park Hill stakes over longer. Before then
I'd like to see her in the Galtres stakes at York. Her trainer, Luca Cumani has
won that race an extraordinary number of times and could easily win it again
with this smart filly.
At a somewhat lower level HAVETOAVIT (35) earned a seriously
good speed figure for a maiden handicap winner at Redcar. He romped home by six
lengths and has clearly not been getting home over the longer distances he's
been racing over. Even with a big penalty he'll still be eligible for class D
and lower grade handicaps, so he should be well worth following.
Over jumps SHALAKO (39) nearly lowered the course record when
scoring at Worcester. I don't know why there are so many smart novice chasers
running in the off season. But in Shalako's case it's almost certainly because
he needs firm ground. He showed here that he's at least as good over fences as
he was over hurdles. On fast ground even First Ballot (the fastest novice chaser
currently running on my ratings) might have trouble beating him.
Shalako adds weight to my long term prediction that come
November we're going to see an unusual pattern to the results of novice chases.
Normally at that time the chasing debutantes fielded by the big stables are more
than good enough to beat the first season fencers that have won before. But this
time around there is strength in depth amongst the current novice chasers, so
I'm betting they'll keep on winning. Several, including Shalako, are seriously
smart.
WATCH THE DOVE (38) who ran second to Shalako, go to within a
length and a half. He pulled a distance clear of the rest while doing so and is
clearly a very novice chaser in his own right. It could be that he's best on a
galloping track and needs fast ground, but there's not enough evidence to say
that for sure yet. I would not care to oppose him next time out. I just hope he
takes on something with a reputation as punters look sure to under-rate this horse
since he's lost all 22 of his starts to date - the vast majority of which came
over hurdles or on soft ground - probably unsuitable conditions for him.
ALKAASED AND FIRST CHARTER ARE VERY SMART
The Group 1 races for older horses have generally
been fought out by a motley crew of sub-standard runners this season. The Sussex
stakes was no exception. It saw Soviet Song (41) and Nayyir (41) fight out the
finish in a time that plenty of Group 2 and Group 3 horses could equal or
better.
There were excuses for some of the losers. Refuse
To Bend had finished eighth or worse in his three previous tries on tight
tracks, so his last place finish here means little. Back on a more galloping
track I'd expect him to bounce back to form. The trouble is his best form only
earned him a rating of 42 which is a tad below average for a Group 1.
Antonius Pius might just have won had he not been
impeded. Haafhd drifted in the betting, and that normally signifies a horse is
unfit, which may have been the case following his lay-off. Le Vie Dei Colori is
another who was almost certainly unfit. Cumani's acquisitions rarely run to
their best first time up for the new stable. Le Vei Dei Colori should therefore
improve. But basically I see nothing very promising from this race. And I think
we're going to see in the Juddmonte International just how weak the older Group
1 horses are generally. With smart three year olds Bago, Azamour and Cacique due
to take part, I'm predicting a wipeout for the older generation.
Actually there are quite a few older horses
lurking around in Listed and Group 3 contests, even handicaps that are running
as fast or nearly as fast as the Group 1 runners. A whole bunch of them met in
the Listed Glorious Stakes at Goodwood. ALKAASED (42) and FIRST CHARTER (42)
pulled well clear of the field to fight out the finish and are now looking very
interesting indeed.
First Charter is a typical five year old improver
from the Stoute barn. It's amazing how often Sir Michael succeeds in bringing a
horse along slowly and then getting it to improve massively as a five year old.
He's turned the trick again with First Charter. I wouldn't under estimate First
Charter. Only two horses have finished in front of him in the last year on good
or faster ground (he obviously hates soft) - Alkaased and Mubtaker, the Arc
second.
Alkaased is a lightly raced four year old who
just keeps on improving. I'd like to see him take a shot at the Canadian
International later on in the year. Meanwhile I rather hope both he and First
Charter take up their engagement in the Geoffrey Freer stakes. Most likely
they'd run 1-2 again and punters would under-value their form, since the best of
it will have been exclusively against each other.
ANCIENT WORLD (39) is another up and comer. He
took the William Hill Mile under a huge weight in Group class time. I mentioned
Ancient World before after he'd run second to Putra Pekan. Putra Pekan has twice
earned Group 1 speed figures from me and is a serious horse when fresh and
racing on good or softer ground. Ancient World is pretty nifty too, and has
seemingly calmed down since being gelded. Whether we'll get any sort of a price
about him when he steps up to Group company is debatable. But he's probably
worth following.
Runner-up IMPELLER (38) has run Group class times
before and did so again here. Unfortunately he alwys seems to hit traffic
problems in big fields as he did here. He broke his maiden in a big field but
has lost all 26 times he's contested races with more than ten runners since. But
for an unlucky short head defeat, he would have won the alst three times he's
been in races with ten runners or less. Clearly the route to go with Impeller
should be to steer him towards Listed and conditions races rather than valuable
handicapos like this where there are always a huge number of runners.
ASTROCHARM (39) has improved dramatically since
stepped up to longer distances. She clocked a time that would win Group 2 races
for fillies when winning a Group 3 at Goodwood over a mile and three quarters.
Her trainer says Astrocharm needs fast ground. She has now won four of the five
times she's raced on officially good to firm or faster ground at 12 furlongs or
more. Reading the reports on her win I get the impression she's still generally
under-rated. It will take a very smart filly to beat her on fast ground at
longer trips, so I reckon she's worth following.
Runner-up PONGEE (39) improved slightly on her
Lancashire Oaks win and also seems to like firm ground. If she hadn't bumped
into such a smart horse here she'd have been winning for the seventh time in
eight tries on fast ground at ten furlongs or more. Pongee would have a shot in
the Yorkshire Oaks. If Luca Cumani runs her in his favorite race, the Galtres
stakes, instead she'd be very hard to beat. Personally I think that would be
'overkill'. He has another filly, Selebela, who'd have a major shot in the
Galtres stakes. If she were mine, I'd be going for the Group 1 prize with
Pongee.
The King George stakes was yet another in a long
line of Group sprints where the runners finished in a heap and the winner.
Ringmoor Down (39) ran just an average time for the class. The Racing Post noted
that three of the first four home in this race are among the first five in the
betting for the Nunthorpe. I can only hope none of them are good enough to win
and that a genuine Group 1 horse like Airwave will encounter the circumstances
required to produce their best in that race.
MAC LOVE(38) ran almost as fast as Ringmo0r Down
when beating the smart Lochridge in a conditions sprint at Doncaster. I confess
that I find it hard to get a handle on this three year old's form. My best shot
is that he needs fast ground and a dead flat, dead straight course. On
officially good to firm or faster ground on tracks without any turns or
gradients whatsoever he would have won six out of six but for two photo finish
defeats. He's entered in the Nunthorpe, and of course that is on exactly his
sort of track. He wouldn't need to improve much to win or go close if he got his
ground.
FONG'S THONG (38) won a Listed race impressively
at Goodwood, running a Group 3 class time once more. The fact that he did not
regress from his big Newbury effort suggests that it probably wasn't as fast as
he can run. He'd only need to improve a point or two to have a shot in the
Celebration Mile on this track. His trainer rates him very highly and is not
usually one to go overboard, so I'd say Fong's Thong remains one to follow.
MEPHISTO (38) ran a Group class time to take a
valuable 1m 6f handicap at Glroious Goodwood despite encountering traffic. He
seems to need a couple of recent runs and is tough to beat when he gets them. In
fact. So far he's run four times when he's had two outings in the previous two
months and won every time. He's looking quite interesting for the Ebor now.
Runner-up SERGEANT CECIL (38) also earned a
chunky speed figure. But I'd give him far less chance in the Ebor. I say this
because he seems to prefer small fields. A small field for most horses is 11
runners or less, and Sergeant Cecil's form on fast ground in fields that small
is very solid. The Ebor field won't be small enough for him but lesser handicaps
at his the longer trips Sergeant Cecil favours generally attract small fields.
So I'd say he's worth following.
Byron (38) earned exactly the same speed figure
as he had at Royal Ascot to win the Group 2 Lennox stakes. He'd need to improve
to take another race at this level, which is why I haven't put his name in
capitals signifying him as a horse I think is worth following.
At Kempton WELCOME STRANGER (36) ran a pretty
good time to take a Classified stakes over a mile. My read of his form is that
he's best at a mile and in smallish fields. In fact, with a bit of racing luck
he would have won the last seven times he's run in fields of 12 or less at a
mile.
The good three year old handicappers just keep on
coming, and ATTUNE (36) added to their number with a clear cut win in unusually
fast time for a class D contest at Newmarket. It looks like Attune needs fast
ground to run her best. If she gets it next time I'd be wary of opposing her in
a class C or D contest.
Not many top class horses make their debuts at
Epsom. Trainers tend to prefer dead flat straight courses to introduce a
youngster to racing. Nonetheless RED PEONY (32) showed that she's probably Group
class when lowering the seven furlong juvenile record on her racecourse debut at
the home of the Blue Riband.
A rating of 32 would be pretty ho hum at five or
six furlongs at this time of year. But over seven it's a bit more interesting
since so few two year olds stay. Red Peony obviously does. In fact she's bred to
get at least ten furlongs. It will take a smart horse to stop her winning in
pattern company next time out. I'd be surprised if we don't see her running in
the Fillies' Mile at Ascot later on.
Red Peony is one of many fast juvenile maiden
winners that I've mentioned here in recent weeks. I've been predicting for a
while that such horses would soon begin overturning the form that has so far
been established in two year old Group races because they've been universally
slow so far. The process began when MONTOGMERY'S ARCH (33) won the Richmond
stakes at Goodwood.
Peter Chapple-Hyam was taking a risk cutting back
Montgomery's Arch to six furlongs from the seven of his debut win. But it paid
off. Montgomery's Arch needs to improve a little to be competitive in the big
two year old races to come. But that seems quite possible if, as planned, he's
stepped back up to the longer distances he's bred for.
Trainer John Gosden is convinced that runner up
MYSTICAL LAND (33) did not like the firm ground here or at Royal Ascot (where he
placed in the Norfolk stakes). For this reason he nominated the Prix Morny in
France as the horse's big target, as the ground is likely to be slower there
since they water more. Right now Mystical Land rates faster than any French two
year old that has run. This isn't really a fair comparison, since the French
race horses at two massively less than the British or the Irish, and their
better juveniles tend to start much later in the season. In any event, Mystical
Land would clearly have a real shot in the Morny. The race normally goes to a
British or Irish runner simply because the top French juveniles have yet to race
when it's run.
|