|
IT WASN’T THE GROUND THAT BEAT BLACK JACK KETCHUM
I’ve never been a huge fan of Black Jack Ketchum (6). So
I wasn’t too surprised to see him get beat in the Cleeve Hurdle at Cheltenham.
What I find truly surprising is that he is still as short as 5-4 to win the
World Hurdle in March.
Believe me, it wasn’t the heavy ground that beat Black
Jack Ketchum. The going was only two fifths of a second per mile faster by my
estimates when he won the Relkeel Hurdle over 2m 5f of the same course last
month.
As I see it, far and away the most likely explanation for
Black Jack Ketchum’s flop is that he failed to stay. Plenty of horses which
can beat novices at three miles prove better at shorter trips when they face
more experienced rivals. And there is strong evidence in Black Jack Ketchum’s
pedigree to suggest he is just this sort of horse. After all, of the other top
26 hurdlers produced by his sire Oscar (based on Raceform ratings) only one
scored at three miles or more. This lone exception was Refinement, and she
clearly got her stamina from her very stoutly bred dam Maneree (a triple winner
over three miles plus). Black Jack Ketchum’s dam Cailin Supreme is nothing
like the same influence for stamina. Yes Cailin Supreme won a couple of slow run
bumper races at two and a half miles. But over hurdles she won three times out
of six at two miles and lost all six times she ran longer. Cailin Supreme is a
sister to Castlekellyleader who won six of her twelve starts at two and a half
miles or less but ran unplaced all three times she went longer. Indeed, nothing
remotely close up on Black Jack Ketchum’s dam’s side scored over three miles
or more.
The form book comments for Black Jack Ketchum’s run read
“quickened to challenge 2 out, ridden well before last and soon beaten”.
Sure sounds like a non-stayer to me.
EXOTIC DANCER STILL NEEDS TO PROVE HE STAYS
I wouldn’t read too much into the result of the Cotswold
Chase won by Exotic Dancer (33) because my ratings say that the visibly slow
pace in the first mile affected the final time. It wasn’t a proper test of
stamina.
Exotic Dancer faded away like an old soldier up the final
hill in the 2005 World Hurdle. My gut feel is that’s exactly what he’ll be
doing in the closing stages of the Gold Cup. In this race he had three serious
challengers with three to jump. Two of them tipped up when still running
strongly and the other clearly failed to stay. So I just can’t rate this run
very highly at all.
I am no longer enthused by the runner-up Our Vic (27)
either. He ran well below his best here despite being fresh as he has been
before all his biggest runs. This was the longest distance, the stiffest track
and the softest ground he’s ever tried. The combination found him out and he
was legless in the closing stages. He literally almost stopped on the run in.
The chances of him getting the Gold Cup trip in a more strongly run race now
look remote. It’s also worth bearing in mind that the progeny of his sire Old
Vic seem to deteriorate with age as early as French bred chasers. Prior to this
latest loss, Old Vic’s progeny aged eight or less had won 73 of their 386
chase starts. His older runners like Our Vic scored just 1 time out of 39.
FLYING ENTERPRISE THE ONE TO BEAT IN JEWSON
FLYING ENTERPRISE (39) clocked a seriously fast time to win
a valuable novices’ handicap chase at the big Cheltenham last week. He has now
won by a big margin all three times that he’s gone longer distances over
fences and looks the one they’ll all have to beat in the Jewson Novices’
Chase at the Festival.
WICHITA LINEMAN DOES IT AGAIN
WICHITA LINE MAN (38) ran another fast time to take a good
Grade 2 novice hurdle at Cheltenham by six lengths. He’d run even faster when
winning the Grade 1 Challow Hurdle at Newbury and deserves to be a short-priced
favourite for the Brit Insurance Novices’ Hurdle at the Festival.
MADISON DU BERLAIS HAS MAJOR CHANCE IN GRAND ANNUAL
MADISON DU BERLAIS (39) is almost boringly consistent at
around two miles. His win at Southwell last week was the fifth time he’s
scored in his last six tries at less than two and a half miles when he’s had a
run within the last month. His sole recent loss at a short trip when fit was a
most unlucky third in the Grand Annual at last year’s Cheltenham Festival. He’ll
be saddled with a fair bit more weight in the same race this year but must have
a great chance of taking it.
URSIS SMART IN MUD
URSIS (37) won a Hereford novice chase in pattern class
time from the useful FOUNTAIN HILL (35). He’s clearly a smart horse when there’s
cut in the ground as he has now won six of the eight times he’s run on
yielding or softer ground when he’s had a run within the last three months. I
imagine his connections will be aiming him at one of the lesser events at the
Cheltenham Festival. If he got his ground there he’d have a shot.
Fountain Hill did very well for a horse whose last run was
nearly two years before. He always looked like making a better chaser than a
hurdler and should have little difficulty taking an ordinary novice chase in the
near future.
CALIFORNIA LAWS IS FAST ON A SLOW SURFACE
CALIFORNIA LAWS (38) won a good class 2 handicap at
Southwell in a time that would take many Group 3 contests. He is clearly a very
smart performer on Fibresand, having won all four times he’s run seven
furlongs or more on the surface. But it may well be that he’ll prove equally
good on soft or heavy turf, seeing that he won so well on heavy ground at
Haydock last year. He’s going to be hard to place since he appears to dislike
normal fast turf or Polytrack and there aren‘t many races on Fibresand he‘s
eligible for. However he looks well worth watching out for when his new
connections manage to find a race for him at Southwell or steer him towards soft
or heavy ground on turf.
SUPER FRANK HASN’T STOPPED WINNING
SUPER FRANK (38) ran remarkably fast to win a class 4
handicap at Lingfield. He has now won four of the five times he’s run seven
furlongs on Polytrack and still looks massively under-rated by the handicapper.
I’d be surprised if he didn’t win again soon.
Runner-up BARNEY MCGREW (36) has only had four starts and
looks sure to be franking this form soon.
MALETTON CAN WIN SOMETHING BETTER
You don't find many dual Listed winners in 0-120 handicap
chases at Fakenham, especially when they're still only seven years of age. But
MALETTON (37) proved he was still capable of winning at that level when running
a fast time to score by six lengths.
Maletton's dam has produced six other foals. Five of them
were steeplechasers and two actually ran over Cross Country courses. So it's not
surprising that Maletton showed little over the flimsy knock over hurdles they
have in Britain. He's done a whole lot better over the fixed brush hurdles they
have in France and over fences in Britain. In fact if he hadn't slipped up at
Sandown he may well have won five of the last six times he's run over bigger
obstacles. His other loss besides Sandown came over two and a half miles, a trip
that's probably too short for him over fences.
Maletton is still a novice, and he's not that far off the
best first season chasers. But his handicap mark is still remarkably low for a
horse of his ability so I imagine his connections will be keen to exploit it
against more experienced chasers again. Either way I'd be wary of opposing
Maletton right now. He's a smart three mile chaser who looks an interesting
candidate for one of the big Cheltenham handicaps over that trip.
AFSOUN NEEDS TO DO A WHOLE LOT MORE
Afsoun (37) ran a very ho hum time to take the so-called
Champion Hurdle Trial at Haydock from the 13 year old The French Furze. I guess
he could do no more than win easily. But he's only run a point quicker than this
on my ratings before and needs to do a whole lot more to rate as any sort of a
threat in the Champion Hurdle itself. He's schooled well over fences already
apparently and may well be an Arkle prospect next year. This year I'd be very
surprised to see him feature at the Cheltenham Festival.
THE NATIONAL IS A YEAR TOO EARLY FOR THE OUTLIER
The Outlier (38) ran a reasonable time to win the peter
Marsh Chase in hock deep mud. But he looks a no-hoper for the Grand National to
me. The stats indicate that very few horses which were novices the previous
season succeed at Aintree. In addition National winners have invariably proven
that they could cope with big fields over big fences. So far The Outlier's wins
have all been in fields of ten or less over fences that claim a low percentage
of fallers. He might be a decent Grand National candidate next year when he's
gained more experience. Right now I wouldn't give him much hope of taking the
big race.
QADAR MIGHT BE THE NEXT LES ARCS
Last year Les Arcs developed into one of the top sprinters
after doing well on the AW during the Winter. This season I'm thinking that
QADAR (40) has a shot of emulating him. True he had a tailwind to help him break
Lingfield's six furlong course record and he only scored narrowly. But he beat
some very smart horses and I rate his win a Group 2 class performance.
Up to now Qadar has been a horse that seems to need a small
field in order to avoid traffic problems. But that's been around a turn. The
runners spread out more on straight courses and I suspect Qadar will handle
bigger fields in such circumstances. So far Qadar has only run three times on
straight courses at six furlongs, and all three runs were back in his two year
old season. He placed against Group 1 horses all three times. I'll be interested
in following him at six furlongs on straight courses once he's switched from the
Poly and the ground has firmed up on turf.
PLAYERS PLEASE AND CHALLIS ARE CLASSIC PROSPECTS
About once every year or so there is a freakishly fast
maiden run on the AW. Normally it involves two smart colts that challenge each
other from a long way out on and pull clear of the field. It is the duel between
two colts of equal ability which produces the fast time. Usually the ability of
both colts is evident and they end up winning separate maidens in much slower
time. It's when they happen to run in the same race that you end up with a time
like the one recorded by PLAYERS PLEASE (38) when he beat CHALLIS (37) at
Wolverhampton.
Players Please was unraced before he won at Wolverhampton
while Challis had run green over distances that are now obviously inadequate for
him. So it's understandable that their connections were unable to take steps to
avoid each other. Their failure highlighted the tremendous ability of their
horses though.
Players Please ran a time that would be getting me
interested in his Epsom prospects if he'd run it in the Sandown Classic Trial in
April or the Lingfield Derby Trial in May. To run this fast over a trip just shy
of ten furlongs in early January is pretty darned incredible.
I note with interest that Players Please is entered in the
Epsom Derby even though I can't find an ante-post price for him, not even on
Betfair. I imagine you might get something like 100-1 if you asked and shopped
around. I wouldn't mind a bit of that each-way.
Challis again ran green yet got to within a length of a
very smart rival. No doubt he'll win a maiden by a big margin next time. After
that he'll surely develop into a contender for Derby trials just like the
winner.
TURN ON THE STYLE BREAKS COURSE RECORD
I noted last week that TURN ON THE STYLE (39) had run
amazingly fast to win at Southwell. I actually gave him a Group class rating for
the win. This being so he looked a good thing for a class 5 handicap at
Lingfield which he duly won.
Turn On The Style would have broken the course record last
time if the going had been a bit quicker. It was on this occasion, so it's no
great surprise he bettered the fastest time previously clocked over five
furlongs at Lingfield.
As I've mentioned before, I'm not yet convinced that Turn
On The Style is over his starting problems. All his wins bar one have been in
fields of ten or less, and I suspect he gets intimidated into starting slowly
when there are more runners than that surrounding him in the stalls. For this
reason I suspect being drawn in the outermost stall was a plus for him here just
as it was when he won from draw ten in another ten runner race at Wolverhampton.
At this stage I'd be inclined to oppose Turn On The Style
in fields bigger than ten, especially when he's drawn close to the rail. Perhaps
I'll be proved wrong. But if he were mine I'd be forgetting about Turn On The
Style's ludicrously low handicap mark and steering him towards pattern races
where the fields tend to be smaller.
TOPIARY IN GREAT SHAPE TO WIN AGAIN
TOPIARY (36) clocked a very decent time to win at
Wolverhampton and has now won three of the four times he's run beyond sprint
distances on the AW (he was hampered in his sole loss). He'll probably still be
eligible for class 5 races after this and he's a good deal better than that
according to my speed ratings. I'd actually make him a good bet to win a class 3
or 4 race. That means he has a good shot of winning again in the near future.
PICADOR SHOULD WIN AGAIN
PICADOR (36) is a typical Mark Prescott horse. After three
sprint runs he was bet to win on his handicap debut at a middle distance. This
is Sir Mark's trademark move and you'd have made a good profit over the years
betting horses he's tried it with. In Picador's case it didn't quite work, he
lost by a neck. But he's won two of his three subsequent outings, most recently
taking a class 6 handicap at Wolverhampton in Listed class time.
Picador reportedly 'ran flat' when running below form on
his next to last outing at Kempton. That doesn't exactly tell us much. My
speculation would be that he doesn't act very well on the slower Polytrack
surface they have at Kempton. Experience in America and Britain seems to be
showing that not all Polytracks are the same. The surface seems peculiarly
sensitive to how its laid and managed particularly in regards to its depth and
how deeply it's harrowed. Just because a horse acts on one Polytrack doesn't
mean it will act on another.
In any event Picador goes to the sales next month. Knowing
Sir Mark, I wouldn't be at all surprised if he doesn't get two or three wins out
of the horse before then by exploiting its remarkably low official handicap
mark.
POUVOIR THE FASTEST JUVENILE HURDLER
Last season we saw what I rated as the best crop of
juvenile hurdlers in decades. So it was inevitable that this season's juveniles
would be disappointing in comparison. However we do now have one young hurdler
that rates as somewhere near the freakishly fast generation we saw last year in
POUVOIR (38) who blew home by 14 lengths at Kempton last Saturday. Lines of form
point the same way as time comparisons, so it's not the funny new distance at
Kempton that's produced Pouvoir's big speed rating. He really is that fast.
Pouvoir would probably have won on his debut but for
falling. Next time out he jumped hesitantly early on, so it seems likely he
should have won on that occasion too instead of losing by half a length to the
smart Degas Art. The only real blip on his record is his third start where his
trainer feels he was brought back to the races too quickly.
This latter comment meshes well with Pouvoir's form which
indicates he runs to what I call the 'rest pattern'. That is he's good for his
first two starts off a three month plus break but then needs a gap of at least
five weeks between his completed starts in order to run well again. Then again,
he's lightly raced, and there's not really enough evidence for me to be
confident about this conclusion. All I can really say for now is that the 33-1
available about Pouvoir's chances in the Triumph Hurdle seems way too big.
CHIEF YEOMAN JUST AS GOOD OVER FENCES
I've never been a great fan of Buena Vista (37). He's only
ever earned Listed class speed ratings from me. So I was happy to oppose him
when he started at odds on for a Hereford Novice Chase. Unfortunately for me he
won. But he still didn't run better than a Listed class time and the horse I
took him on with, CHIEF YEOMAN (37) would have won but for stumbling at the
last.
There were several reasons I was keen on Chief Yeoman.
Firstly he'd run faster than Buena Vista according to my ratings. Secondly, his
trainer, Venetia Williams, had run ten horses over fences in the last decade
whose most recent official hurdle rating was 130 or more like Chief Yeoman's.
Five of the ten won on their chasing debuts. Secondly Chief Yeoman's sire,
Machiavellian, had done well with his few chasing runners. He'd had six that
were rated 110 or more officially over hurdles that ran over fences. Three of
the six won on their first start over fences.
Sadly the stats weren't quite borne out this time as Chief
Yeoman went under by a short head. However Venetia Williams' charge now looks a
better Arkle prospect than the winner and will be awfully hard to beat next
time.
LADALKO IS AMAZINGLY CONSISTENT ON LEFT-HANDED TRACKS
LADALKO (40) is much better at jumping fences when going
left-handed according to his trainer. And he proved him right when taking the
valuable totesport.com Classic Chase at Warwick. In doing so he ran a time that
marks him out as one of the top contenders for the Grand National.
Ladalko would have won all five times he's gone left-handed
over fences but for a half length loss at Stratford over an inadequate trip and
a short head defeat in the Scottish National. He has yet to win and has fallen
three times in six chase starts on right handed courses.
The big concern about Ladalko's prospects at Aintree is
obviously his jumping. Indeed Aintree's fences are always a daunting challenge
for the relatively lighter-framed French bred chasers such as him. However there
are now so many French-bred jumpers in Britain that the huge losing streak
they've had in the Grand National has to end some day and Ladalko could easily
be the one to do the job.
Runner-up MON MOME (39) is also a French bred. But he was a
novice last year and is not a big horse according to his trainer so he has three
huge strikes against him in regards to Aintree. I'd oppose him with some
confidence there but elsewhere he's going to be tough to beat.
Mon Mome is way too consistent to be just another staying
handicap chaser. Give him a bit of cut in the ground and a recent run and he
always runs his race. In fact his last two starts are the first chases he's lost
in six tries in these conditions. In one of the defeats he was second to Halcon
Genelardais and here he ran second to Ladalko, giving both of these smart
chasers a real fight.
Mon Mome looks nailed on to win a big staying handicap
chase sometime this season. I'm pretty sure it won't be the Grand National. But
in anything else I'd be wary of opposing him.
NAUNTON BROOK (39) ran his best ever race to finish third.
He's a bold jumping front runner who has never fallen in 16 chase starts and
stays all day. So he actually looks a better prospect for the Grand National
than the horses which beat him. He's improved steadily with each season he's
raced and clearly excels on tracks with steep uphill finishes. So if he gets
outpaced on Aintree's dead flat track in the National I'd still be interested in
his chances in the Betfred Gold Cup at Sandown where the steep final climb
should suit him down to the ground.
IDOLE FIRST STILL SMART WHEN FRESH
IDOLE FIRST (38) ran about as fast as he ever has to win a
hot class 3 handicap chase at Kempton. The trick with him seems to be the
spacing of his runs. He has now won seven of the ten times he's had a break of
five weeks or more between his runs but lost all 13 times he's been brought back
more quickly. On this run he'd have a shot of bagging another Cheltenham
Festival win if he's rested until the big meeting. But I wouldn't want to bet on
him replicating this form if he's brought out again before February 17th, five
weeks from the run.
Runner-up LASKARI (37) looks a bit more likely to win in
the immediate future. As I see it, the big clue to his form is that he's been
largely restricted to right-handed tracks despite the fact that two thirds of UK
courses are left-handed. Clearly his connections think he prefers going right
and Laskari's form suggests they are correct It also seems likely that the horse
does not get home on stiff tracks. But he'd won the two previous times he'd run
on an easy right-handed track and ran a big race here. So next time he runs on
an easy right-handed course like Kempton I'd be very interested in his chances.
TORKINKING HAS A SHOT IN CHAMPION HURDLE TRIAL
TORKINKING (38) is a tough front runner to pull back when
he's allowed his own way up front in a small field on soft ground at the minimum
distance. He had his ideal conditions when romping home by ten lengths at
Wetherby and looks set to have them again when he lines up for the Champion
Hurdle Trial at Haydock this coming weekend. Haydock strongly favours front
runners like Torkinking so I'm going to be very interested in his chances on
Saturday.
NIRVANA DU BOURG LOOKS INTERESTING FOR THE PERTEMPS
FINAL
ROWLEY HILL (36) failed to score when tried over fences
last season. But he's clearly a useful staying hurdler, as he showed when
winning a Pertemps qualifier at Warwick last week.
My research indicates that most horses overjump and lose in
their first two hurdles starts after going chasing. So I think Rowley Hill's two
losses when he reverted to the smaller obstacles last season are excusable. He's
won four of his other most recent starts at three miles plus over hurdles and
looks a better prospect for the final of this race at Cheltenham than for novice
chases, seeing that he jumped badly every time he tried the bigger obstacles
last term.
Interesting as Rowley Hill is, the horse to take out of the
race as I see it is NIRVANA DU BOURG (34).
Nirvana Du Bourg wasn't that far off the top chasers in
France according to my speed ratings (I gave him a rating of 39 for his best
recent run). It may well be that he fared less well over hurdles simply because
the races weren't long enough for him over there. He did fine over three miles
here on his first run over British hurdles which are much more flimsy than those
he's used to. Once he's had another run over them to get his eye in I'd see him
as a very good prospect for the final of this race. And if trainer Nicky
Henderson decides to revert him to fences I'd still see him as a good candidate
for one of the big Cheltenham handicaps.
TURN ON THE STYLE LIVES UP TO HIS NAME
There have been 773 races run over six furlongs on
Southwell's Fibresand track in the last eleven years. When he bolted up by three
lengths last week TURN ON THE STYLE (39) ran the ninth fastest time in this
period despite the fact he wasn't racing on particularly fast going. Clearly
he's a very smart sprinter.
In the past Turn On The Style has spoilt his chances by
playing up at the start and losing a lot of ground when the stalls opened. He
didn't do that this time. It could be he's over the problem. But I reckon that a
lot of sprinters habitually lose ground at the start because it is the most
crowded point of a race. In my experience I've found that sprinters which lose
ground at the start are often better in smaller fields. In this regard I note
with interest that Turn On The Style has finished first or second the last seven
times he's run in fields of ten or less as he did here. Certainly he'll be
interesting next time however many runners line up. But I'd be more confident of
his chances in a race where he faces nine or fewer rivals.
MAGIC GLADE BACK TO HIS BEST
I can remember a few years ago being very impressed with
the fast times MAGIC GLADE (38) consistently ran on Fibresand. Seeing that he's
now eight years of age, I thought all that was behind him. But apparently not.
New trainer Tom Dascombe somehow got the old boy back to his very vest form on
only his second start for the new handler.
I confess that I've never really understood just why
Britain has the vast majority of the best sprinters in Europe. But for whatever
reason, I'd estimate there are at least ten times more horses capable of winning
foreign Group races in Britain at 5-6f than there are at middle distances.
Nonetheless, in the class 4 races that Magic Glade is still eligible for,
ability such as his is still rare. This being so I'd say he's likely to win
again soon before he's forced to tackle the Group class sprinters which run in
class 3 & higher.
PABLO DU CHARMIL DOES IT AGAIN
PABLO DU CHARMIL (40) earned another huge speed rating from
me when scoring by 23 lengths at Warwick. He didn't manage to win over the
flimsy hurdles they have in Britain. But over the fixed brush hurdles they have
in France and in steeplechases he's now won five times out of five - earning the
same monster speed rating on three of those occasions.
My only concern with Pablo Du Charmil now is that he takes
so much out of himself by running fast so often that he may well need to be
fresh in order to run to form. In this regard I note with interest that all his
wins conform to what I call the rest pattern. That is he's good for his first
two starts off a long break but then needs at least five weeks between his
completed starts thereafter. This being so I'd like to see him rested between
now and the Arkle. If he runs again within less than five weeks he'll probably
'bounce' off this run. And if he runs again later on he won't have enough time
to recover before Cheltenham. Unless that is he runs on the 5th or 6th of
February - which would leave him five weeks between this run and also before
Cheltenham.
In any event Pablo Du Charmil is one of the very best
novice chasers we've seen this season and should be able to take a Grade 1
contest. Next season he ought to be a Champion Chase prospect.
GENTLEMAN'S DEAL ONE OF THE BEST AW HORSES EVER
The Fibresand surface at Southwell is slower than it was.
So GENTLEMAN'S DEAL (42) should really have broken the track record when he won
a red hot class 2 handicap over a mile there the other day. As it is he ran the
fastest time over the course and distance in the last six years, having set the
previous fastest time in the same period himself a year earlier.
Gentleman's Deal now ranks as one of the best AW horses
ever on my speed ratings and is unbeaten in five starts on sand. However I think
it is highly be significant that his three Fibresand runs have produced pattern
class times while his two Polytrack efforts have been a whole lot slower. He's
hung in both his Polytrack wins too and kept straight as a die on his Fibresand
starts. This leads me to believe he is not comfortable racing on the much faster
Polytrack surface and therefore unable to produce the same level of form he can
on Fibresand.
It seems a shame that Gentleman's Deal is six years of age
and has only won 50,000 pounds. Horses with his level of ability in America
normally win at least ten times that much. If he were mine I'd be shipping him
to America right away and running him in New York where the tracks are still
traditional dirt and not Polytrack.
Runner-up SPEEDY SAM (40) showed remarkable versatility by
running as fast as he had last time despite the switch from Polytrack to
Fibresand and the drop in distance from ten furlongs to a mile. He was unlucky
to come up against such a smart rival and continues to look a very good prospect
for the Winter Derby.
UHOOMAGOO (39) is very smart on firm turf at seven furlongs
but seems happy over a bit longer on the AW. He’d won his two most recent
starts on Fibresand before this so clearly likes the surface. It’s interesting
to note that he’d also won his only recent start on Wolverhampton’s
Polytrack but run below form in his seven AW starts at Kempton and Lingfield.
The key to him seems to be a strong pace and a strong pace is far more common on
Fibresand than Polytrack. So at this point I’d prefer his chances back here at
Southwell if he can be found another race or else at Wolverhampton in an event
where a strong pace seemed likely. In the right conditions he’s capable of
beating Group class rivals.
BAHAR SHUMAAL TOUGH TO BEAT ON POLY
BAHAR SHUMAAL (39) earned the biggest speed rating I've
given a horse on the AW in years when breaking the course record for 1m 1f &
103 yards at Wolverhampton in October. And he again ran a seriously fast time
when returning to the course and distance to take a red hot Class 2 handicap.
Bahar Shumaal didn't run quite as fast as he did in
November. Nonetheless he ran quick enough to win many Group 2 contests.
Unfortunately he left open the question of whether he will settle well enough to
win at the slow pace most Polytrack races are run at. He'd spoiled his chances
by pulling like a train in more slowly run races at Lingfield. Here though,
thanks to the tearaway Weightless, he had a strong pace to run at.
I'd still like to see Bahar Shumaal try his luck in
America. He's run as fast as Hal's Pal, River Keen and Running Stag did on the
AW in Britain. And those horses each went on to win millions of dollars on dirt
in America. In Europe he's going to have to clock up a lot of air miles to find
pattern races to run in on the AW. Either that or he'll have to take another
shot at running on grass which I think would be a shame as he's clearly so much
better on sand.
Runner-up VACATION (39) looks a better prospect to show the
same form on grass since it looks like the stepmup in trip rather than the
switch to the AW that's produced his recent improvement. It looks like he found
a mile too short on the lightning fast surface at Lingfield. But he would have
won his other three AW starts before this but for pulling hard and hanging when
going under by half a length one time.
Vacation looks likely to do well when he's stepped up to
ten furlongs, so, like the winner, he looks a good prospect for the Winter Derby
in March. Meanwhile he should be able to win pretty much any race he runs in, as
long as it's not over a mile at Lingfield.
Third placed LANGFORD (37) showed that he is as good as
ever at seven years of age. He'd shown steady improvement since coming back off
a lay-off to run on the AW. Prior to that he'd won four of the seven times he'd
run 8-9.5f on good to firm or faster ground in fields of ten or less and run
close seconds in two of his losses. Fields that small are the norm on the AW so
Langford looks set to win soon.
KINDLELIGHT DEBUT (37) won a whole bunch of AW races from
January to March last year and looks to be hitting form at the same time now.
I'd bet on him winning again in the very near future.
WILL HATTAN ACT ON DIRT IN DUBAI?
Clive Brittain has an amazing knack of picking the right
horses to switch to the AW. In fact you'd have more than trebled your money if
you'd bet the horses aged three and up with official ratings of 80 or more that
he's given their first start on the AW in the last eleven years. This being so
it's no surprise that HATTAN (39) was able to make a winning AW debut at
Wolverhampton, and ran as fast as he ever has on turf.
My read of Hattan is that he has been running the wrong
distance or racing on the wrong ground for much of his career.
I think Hattan's connections got misled into thinking he
was a 12 furlong horse by the fact that he won the Chester Vase over that
distance. But the Chester Vase was a slowly run race and Chester is a very tight
track, and it's perfectly possible for a ten furlong horse to last a mile and a
half in such circumstances.
Since losing on his racecourse debut Hattan has run four
times over ten furlongs or less on good or softer turf. The first time was when
he was an unlucky in running third in the Classic Trial at Sandown. The second
was when he ran a close second in Group 2 class time to the very smart older
horse Eccentric as a three year old (he might well have won that day had he not
raced alone) The third time was when he ran a close third to subsequent Group 1
winner Notnowcato. The fourth time was when he ran second in a Group 1 last time
out to triple Group 1 winner Cherry Mix.
In my experience Polytrack quite often suits horses like
Hattan that are one paced on grass. It takes the edge off their rivals'
acceleration. The question now is 'will Hattan act on dirt' in Dubai? His sire
Halling won on dirt at Nad Al Sheba but that was against other turf performers
in very slow time. He flopped against high class dirt rivals on the surface in
the States. His dam produced a Nad Al Sheba winner too in Luzern. But that was
on grass. Luzern failed to place in a whole string of outings on dirt. On
balance therefore I'm inclined to think Hattan won't do well in Dubai as the
turf will be too firm and his pedigree says he won't like dirt. But when he gets
back to Britain I see him winning something decent at ten furlongs or less on
good or slower going.
Runner up RED SPELL (39) continues to be one of Europe's
top AW horses despite losing no less than 21 races in a row. His problem appears
to be that he is a hold up horse who needs a stronger pace than normally
prevails on the Polytrack. This being so I'd imagine his big target will once
again be the Pramms Memorial on real dirt at Jagersro in May.
KING OF MUSIC BETTER THAN SELLING CLASS
I don't know why KING OF MUSIC (34) improved so much to win
a seller by ten lengths at Lingfield. All I can say is that the time he clocked
suggests strongly he should follow up this win in better company for his new
connections.
BOHEMIAN SPIRIT BETTER AT SHORTER TRIPS
BOHEMIAN SPIRIT (38) frequently gets himself worked up
before his races and then tears off into the lead. So the cut back to two miles
looks like a smart move. He ran a tremendous race over the trip to be a close
second to Kalca Mome who I rate a Grade 2 horse on my ratings. He'd won his
three previous completed starts over jumps at two and a half miles or less. And
now he's gone and bolted up in fast time at Sandown over the minimum distance.
Nicky Richards said in the past that he didn't want to run
Bohemian Spirit on soft or heavy ground. Indeed until last time out he'd failed
to complete all three times he'd run on such going. But now it's clear that was
simply because he tired badly in the going. At two miles he's handled mud
perfectly fine on his last two outings.
I've now awarded Bohemian Spirit pattern class speed
ratings on several occasions and, seeing how consistent he is at shorter
distances, I suspect he has a won or two more left in him this season.
SILVERBURN MAY NEED MORE TIME
SILVERBURN (39) clocked a very respectable time for a
novice to win Sandown's Grade 1 Tolworth Hurdle. On the clock he's as good as
his brother Denman. And it's tempting to view the pair in exactly the same way.
However I need to see him prove that he can produce this same level of
performance on faster ground. I also want him to show that he can settle well
enough to last two and a half miles. My gut feel is that he's greener than
Denman was at this stage and may be even more suited to the bigger jumps than
his brother. On the plus side his trainer seems to understand him very well so
it looks like he'll be putting him in the right races at the right time. On
balance though, I have to say that, in a season where there are so many smart
Irish novice hurdlers, if this is the best the British have got then the big
novice hurdles at Cheltenham are heading Ireland's way.
Silverburn did actually beat an Irish challenger home in
PERCE ROCK (37) who is clearly very promising.
It may well be that Perce Rock's trainer Tommy Stack is
right in saying that the horse was still not fully fit as he'd run a fair bit
faster when finishing a somewhat unlucky fourth in the Cheltenham Festival
Bumper. In addition he did seem to be going best turning in and may well have
simply blown up through lack of fitness in the closing stages. I suspect he has
a better chance of scoring at the Cheltenham Festival than the winner and look
forward to his next run.
PAPINI IS SMART WHEN HE CAN GET TO THE LEAD
PAPINI (39) clocked a fast time to win the valuable
ladbroke.com handicap hurdle at Sandown. But it seems clear from his form that
he's unlikely to do well in the Totesport Trophy at Newbury if that race
attracts more than a dozen runners as seems likely.
My read of Papini's form is that he is what American
punters call a 'need to lead' front runners. That is, he will only run his best
when he is able to get to the lead.
Papini did make all the running to win an ordinary novice
hurdle with 14 runners. But he's been unable to get to the lead or win in five
subsequent starts in fields bigger than twelve.
At two miles in a field of twelve or less Papini looks
capable of being competitive with just about anything. So, if he were mine, I'd
be steering him towards conditions hurdles rather than trying to exploit his
admittedly lenient official rating in big handicaps where large fields are the
norm.
MISTER POTTER IS A GOOD CHASING PROSPECT
The fixed brush hurdles at Haydock are midway between
hurdles and fences in terms of how much they slow the runners down. So it's not
surprising that races over the obstacles are mostly contested by chasing sorts
like MISTER POTTER (36). Richard Lee's charge is a big, rangy, obvious future
chaser who has already run over fences in a point to point. He blew home by 14
lengths over the fixed brush hurdles in very decent time.
I rather doubt that Mister Potter will be able to show the
same level of form over normal hurdles. But when he switches back to fences or
runs over fixed brush hurdles again he'll be hard to beat.
MY WAY DE SOLZEN'S WIN DIDN'T TELL US MUCH
The race between MY WAY DE SOLZEN (36) and TURKO (30)
looked like being one of the highlights of the season. But sadly all it told us
was that Turko can't jump fences effectively out of heavy ground. He made a
series of blunders which enabled his rival to cruise home by a big margin in
much slower time than the pair of them have run multiple times before.
Turko's poor run also raises the question of whether he can
act on undulating tracks. Previously I'd thought his poor runs were caused by
him needing to be fresh. But he was fresh here and it's worrying to note that
he's now lost all five times he's run on undulating tracks but won five of the
six times he's run on dead flat runs since losing on his hurdling debut. My
inclination now is to see him as an Aintree rather than a Cheltenham prospect.
TOO FORWARD IS SMART IN SMALL FIELDS
TOO FORWARD (36) is a quirky horse. You just can't touch
his mouth during a race according to his jockeys, and his record suggests he's
shy of racing in a crowd. However soft ground tends to spread the runners out in
a race enough to ensure he runs well in small fields. In fact he's now won five
of the six times he's run in fields of ten or less on what I rate yielding or
softer ground. His sole loss was a good second off a two year lay off when he
ran all over the place - presumably because he was ridden harder than he likes.
Too Forward didn't have to be ridden hard at all to cruise
home in his favoured circumstances in the valuable Unicoin Homes Chase at
Cheltenham.
Too Forward has run faster than this (39 on my scale).
Nonetheless he does look to be a bit hard to place. If he goes for the big
Conditions races like the Ryanair Chase he's always likely to find one or two
too good for him. If he goes for handicaps he's likely to find more runners than
he's comfortable with. Still, in small fields and on soft ground he's a horse to
have a lot of respect for.
REBELLIOUS SPIRIT SHOULD WIN AGAIN
REBELLIOUS SPIRIT (36) came back off a six month break to
run much his fastest race over a mile at Southwell. And he improved markedly
again when running away with a class 5 handicap over the same course and
distance last week. Clearly he's a whole lot better than his official rating
says he is. The plus is that last year his best form was on Polytrack. So it
looks likely that he'll be able to follow up this win whatever surface he runs
on next time.
VOY POR USTEDES SHOULD NOT BE CHAMPION CHASE FAVOURITE
VOY POR USTEDES (39) won the Desert Orchid Chase in decent
style despite being prompted to jump left by the riderless Armaturk. But he
continues to run no faster than he did as a novice chaser. And I suspect that he
won't until he's stepped up to two and a half miles.
Most of the better jumpers by Voy Por Ustedes' sire Villez
were better over two and a half miles plus. His dam was a stayer on the flat.
Her sole win came at the longest trip she ever tried - 1m 7f. And the two other
foals she's produced which placed over jumps both ran their best races at 2m 5f
or more.
I can't understand why Voy Por Ustedes is now favourite for
the Two Mile Champion Chase. On what he's shown I just can't consider him to be
a viable candidate for that race. His pedigree and the way he always stays on so
strongly prompts me to suggest that he'll only show the improvement most good
chasers make from their novice careers when he's stepped up to two and a half
miles or more.
I have a principle that I follow: 'A horse is at its best
at the outermost limits of its stamina'. I reckon Voy Por Ustedes will be at his
best over longer than two miles and hope to see him contest the Ryanair Chase
not the Champion Chase at the Cheltenham Festival.
LIMERICK BOY SHOULD WIN A BIG RACE THIS SEASON
22 months ago LIMERICK BOY (43) ran astonishingly fast to
win a Grade 2 chase by a dozen lengths from subsequent Betfred Gold Cup winner
Lacdoudal. Now he's gone and done it again by hammering the multiple Grade 1
placed ROYAL EMPEROR (37) by sixteen lengths at Haydock.
Royal Emperor tends to have jumping problems in big fields
over fences and can get outpaced on fast ground. But he'd won seven of the nine
previous times he'd completed the course on yielding or softer ground, and in
fields of eight or less if it was over fences. So he figured to run to his best,
which is what my speed ratings say he did - at least his recent best (he used to
be faster when he was younger).
My explanation for Limerick Boy's failure to show this
level of form all the time is that he dislikes undulating tracks. On undulating
tracks Limerick Boy has lost all eleven of his jump starts. But on tracks
without significant undulations he has won six of his nine completed starts. One
of his losses was a smart second to Back In Front in the Grade 1 Champion Novice
Hurdle at the Punchestown Festival. Another was his last start where he switched
back to hurdles - and chasers invariably overjump and lose their first two runs
when they return to hurdling.
On this run I would bet Limerick Boy to beat just about
anything on a dead flat track. If he were mine the race I'd be shooting for is
next month's Racing Post Chase.
Royal Emperor will be worth betting the next time he
encounters a small field and soft ground below Grade 1 or 2 class.
JACK THE GIANT CLIMBS TO THE TOP
JACK THE GIANT (40) stretched his unbeaten run over fences
to three by winning the Grade 2 Wayward Lad Novice Chase at Kempton's Christmas
meeting. In doing so he earned the joint highest speed rating I've given a
novice chaser so far this term. He actually ran faster than last year's Arkle
winner Voy Por Ustedes managed in a true run race over the same course and
distance later on the card.
I suspect that jockey Mick Fitzgerald is right to say that
Jack The Giant will stay longer than two miles. He's stayed on strongly in his
races and got outpaced here before rallying to great effect. This extra stamina
will stand him in good stead for the Arkle, a race that's often won by a horse
that stays two and a half miles.
Trainer Nicky Henderson says that Jack The Giant needs good
ground and my going allowance says that's what he raced on here. Good ground is
often hard to come by between now and the Cheltenham Festival so I doubt that
we'll be seeing much of Jack The Giant before then. However Nicky Henderson is
brilliant at getting his runners fit at home, and he specialises in winning at
Cheltenham's big meeting as much as he does over the Christmas period. This
being so I have to rate Jack The Giant right up there with Pablo Du Charmil at
the top of my short list for the Arkle and see the 20-1 being offered by
Ladbrokes as plain silly. Then again Pablo Du Charmil is 33-1 which is even
sillier.
I'm not yet sure what to make of the runner-up TWIST MAGIC
(39). But I find it interesting that his three big UK runs have come on tight
tracks while he's run absolute clunkers all three times he's run on galloping
courses. This being so I have to conclude he's more of an Aintree than a
Cheltenham or Punchestown prospect. Though I have to add that his one bad run on
a tight track did come at Aintree - though I'm betting he had some sort of
problem there as he was off for eight months afterwards.
It may also be significant that Twist Magic had won the
last three times he's run on what my going allowances say was soft or heavy
ground and lost the five times he's encountered a faster surface. Mitigating
against this is the fact the ran really well on what I rated good ground here.
In any event Twist Magic is undoubtedly one of the top novice chasers. I'd be
wary of opposing him on a tight track but somewhat cautious about his prospects
on galloping tracks or faster ground.
WICHITA LINESMAN A VERY SMART STAYING HURDLER
Novice hurdlers don't run much faster than WICHITA LINESMAN
(40) did to win the Grade 1 Challow Hurdle at Newbury. This run makes him the
one they all have to beat in long distance novice hurdles from now on. Quite why
he lost by half a length at Cheltenham I can't say. Perhaps he needs a greater
test of stamina which he got here thanks to much softer ground and a far
stronger early pace. Certainly he stays very well and looks a future World
Hurdle candidate.
SIR JIMMY SHAND (37) didn't run that far below the very
smart form he showed on his previous outing to take second. He's an out and out
chaser on pedigree, and his trainer Nicky Henderson says that anything he does
over hurdles is a bonus. So there has to be some doubt that Sir Jimmy Shand is
going to be capable of winning a Grade 1 over the smaller jumps. He is
undoubtedly one of the better staying novice hurdlers though and will always be
a threat in any race where stamina is at a premium.
HALCON GENELARDAIS NOT FAR OFF GOLD CUP CLASS
HALCON GENELARDAIS (40) won the Welsh National in very fast
time. In fact my speed ratings say he would have got to within ten or fifteen
lengths of the winner in the average Cheltenham Gold Cup on this run.
I can see why trainer Alan King says Halcon Genelardais is
not likely to be suited to the Grand National. The horse's only loss in five
chase starts came in the 30 runner Scottish National where he made repeated
jumping errors - presumably because he disliked being crowded at the jumps. It
seems more logical to take a shot at the Gold Cup which is apparently the plan.
King has expressed concerns about keeping Halcon
Genelardais fresh in the past, so now that he's racing against experienced
rivals I'd be wary of betting him for the rest of this season unless he's given
a break of at least five weeks between his starts. With that proviso, I have to
say he looks a very interesting horse right now. I can't dismiss his Gold Cup
chances at this stage.
Runner-up MON MOME (39) is a very good horse to have an
official handicap rating of only 136. He's won at the Aintree Festival, run
second at the Cheltenham Festival and won four of his five completed chases when
he's had a recent run (this was his sole loss). He'll surely be placed to win
something big before long.
AMARETTO ROSE IS A SMART MARE
AMARETTO ROSE (37) ran away with a decent novice hurdle and
is clearly a smart mare. This was her third wide margin win in four lifetime
starts. Apparently her owners are keen to retire her to stud but I imagine
they'll want to earn some black type with her first. She'll probably have to run
against males to do that, but on this run she's well up to winning a Listed or
Grade 3 novice hurdle.
KENZO III A CHELTENHAM PROSPECT
KENZO III (40) overcame a near two year lay-off to win a
red hot handicap chase at Hereford. Trainer Nicky Henderson is a proper
old-fashioned horseman whose patience has been rewarded with a performance that
makes Kenzo III look a serious Cheltenham prospect. The obvious target would be
the Racing Post Plate (formerly the Mildmay Of Flete) because Kenzo III will
still be exceptionally well handicapped even if he goes up a couple of stone in
the official ratings between now and March.
Kenzo III has already own over three miles, so longer races
are clearly an option. But whatever he goes for I'd keep a close watch on him.
Kenzo III looks nailed on to win a big handicap chase sometime this season.
Runner-up KALCA MOME (40) is a horse I've had several
theories about in the past. But this run seemed to confirm that he's basically a
soft ground specialist.
My read of Kalca Mome's form now is that he prefers soft or
heavy ground, is best at 2m 3f or less, needs a recent run and over fences must
have ten runners or less. He's won five of the last seven times he's met this
combination of circumstances and will be a threat if he meets them again any
time soon.
HOO LA BALOO (39) ran his best race by far since his riding
tactics were altered. He'd run seriously fast over two miles as a novice when
allowed to tear off into the lead at a furious pace. But towards the end of last
season his trainer Paul Nicholls said "We think he's going to be a nice
horse over two and a half miles next season so we wanted to start riding him
differently." At first the new style of racing didn't seem to suit Hoo La
Baloo. But the step up to 2m 3f here saw him return to his best. So it looks
like Nicholls is right. Hoo La Baloo is going to be a nice horse over two and a
half miles this season. Nicholls has also said that Hoo La Baloo "seems to
need to go right-handed". This looks spot on as his four starts on
left-handed tracks have been dreadful. At around two and a half miles on
right-handed tracks I'd be wary of opposing Hoo La Baloo in anything but a
championship level contest.
ALMAYDAN (38) equalled his best ever performance on my
ratings to finish a close fourth. In doing so he proved that he does get longer
than two miles. I reckon he's best on genuinely good or slower ground in fields
of eleven or less. He's more than capable of winning a decent chase in these
circumstances.
KAUTO STAR PROVES ME WRONG
KAUTO STAR (42) became only the second horse since Istabraq
to win three Grade 1 races in the space of ten weeks when taking the King
George. I honestly thought he couldn't do it but Kauto Star proved me wrong.
Putting a number on Kauto Star's performance is
problematic. Race times and the Turftrax going stick readings indicate the going
was the same on both days of the Kempton meeting. And the two mile chases on the
second day came a whole lot closer to the standard times than Kauto Star managed
in the King George. This means that logically I should award Kauto Star a really
low speed rating of around 30 on my scale. But he did run a good deal faster
than both the chases run on the 26th, so somewhat reluctantly, I'm going to
assume that the ground speeded up on the chase course on the second day.
I'm not sure that Kauto Star beat that much here. So I
remain skeptical of his prospects against the top Irish chasers, none of whom
turned up for the King George. I want to see him run an unequivocally fast time
before I start joining his fan club. The 6-4 available about him for the Gold
Cup is plain daft in my book.
The one to take out of the race is probably RACING DEMON
(39). It’s almost unheard of for a horse to win when it is stepped up to three
miles for the first time in a Grade 1 non-novice chase like this. So he did well
to finish third, especially since he didn’t settle in the early stages (often
a problem when a horse goes a longer trip for the first time). He’s run as
fast as the top Irish chasers and still has serious potential. This being so I
think the 25-1 now being offered about his Gold Cup chances by Ladbrokes is way
out of line
MONET’S GARDEN (25) almost certainly failed to stay the
distance. He had won a couple of races at three miles and finished second in
another. But there were all slow run races according to my speed ratings. The
only previous times he'd really had his stamina tested were the occasions he was
asked to run beyond two and a half miles at Cheltenham. These two runs are the
worst in his record other than this run. Back over two and a half miles there
are still big races to be won with this smart horse.
JAZZ MESSENGER PROBABLY NOT QUITE CHAMPION CLASS
JAZZ MESSENGER (40) won a weak renewal of the Christmas
Hurdle at Kempton in Grade 2 class time. He keeps on running a bit faster but he
has a mountain to climb to catch up to Detroit City and Hardy Eustace on the
clock. In any event I suspect he’s always going to be best in small fields
such as the one he met here. He’s been hampered the last two times he ran over
hurdles in big fields and his jockey said after the race that he’s a horse who
dislikes being crowded. No doubt this explains some of his past jumping
problems. I can see Jazz Messenger winning more big conditions hurdles in small
fields on the soft ground he seems to need. But the normal big field and fast
ground of the Champion Hurdle would surely not suit him.
TROUBLE AT BAY ONE OF THE BETTER NOVICE CHASERS
TROUBLE AT BAY (37) was one of the best juvenile hurdlers a
couple of seasons ago but had to be laid off for two years. He showed that he's
as good as ever when winning on his chasing debut at Hereford and now ranks as
one of the better novice chasers. The problem is that there are an awful lot of
smart novice chasers around this season, especially at two miles which seems to
be Trouble At Bay's distance. So he'll need to run a bit faster than this to get
me enthused about his Arkle prospects. In non-pattern company though he's going
to be tough to beat.
ECHO POINT COULD BE ANYTHING
ECHO POINT (39) ran away with a Sedgefield Novice Chase by
22 lengths. In all his races he’s charged into the lead and often pulled hard.
So I rather wonder if he’ll get home on a track with a steep uphill finish at
Cheltenham seeing that he didn’t seem to do so at Carlisle. Nonetheless this
run marks him out as one of the better novice chasers. On a tight track I’d be
wary of betting against him.
PALUA IS STILL GOOD WHEN IT’S GOOD
PALUA (38) is almost unstoppable at the minimum distance on
a dead flat track when the ground is good. He needs these conditions to ensure
he gets home. He had them at Wincanton over Christmas and he only just got beat
in very fast time for the class. This is unfortunate as it must be hard to find
suitable races for Palua. But from a betting point of view it’s great because
the horse demonstrated that he’s as good as ever and well worth betting the
next time he runs in a race on fast ground on a dead flat track at two miles.
PEARL KING (38) did awfully well for a novice to beat such
a smart and experienced rival. He too clearly needs fast ground and two miles.
In addition it looks obvious that he prefers to go right-handed. I guess he’s
really more of a Summer jumper, but he’s fast enough to win something decent
in the Winter if he gets his ground.
CUSOON IS GROUP CLASS
CUSOON (39) lowered the course record when he won a red hot
10f handicap at Lingfield. True, the track has been riding faster than ever this
past week, but it was still a good Group class performance. Cusoon also earned a
Group class speed rating from me the last time he ran and is clearly one of the
very best horses currently racing on Polytrack.
The plan now apparently is to rest Cusoon until the flat
season proper. This makes sense as five of his six wins to date have come in his
first three starts off a break or with a five week plus rest. In addition he's
been very lucky to experience such a strong early pace in his last two starts.
The strong pace helped him according to his trainer Gary Moore, but it's far
from being the norm on the Polytrack.
Cusoon had never shown anything like the level of form he's
displayed in his last two starts on either Polytrack or grass before. So I'm
inclined to believe he'll now be just as much improved on grass, providing he
gets the firm ground he needs.
Having said all that, if I were Cusoon's owner I'd still be
awfully tempted to bring the horse back in March and have a shot at the Winter
Derby. He wouldn't need (or probably even want) a prep race seeing that he goes
so well fresh. So that would mean he'd have three months off and have a major
chance of taking down a big prize before at a time when the going on turf would
probably be too soft for him.
Runner-up WATAMU (38) looked a very promising three year
old in 2004 when he showed a distinct preference for fast ground and tight
tracks. He showed that he is still as good as ever despite a break of over two
years before this run. He too looks a viable candidate for the Winter Derby.
Meanwhile he should be able to exploit what is clearly a laughably low official
handicap rating.
Third-paled STARGAZER JIM (37) doesn't seem to handle soft
ground or stay beyond ten furlongs. But at 8.5f to 10f he's run nothing but good
races on Polytrack and firm turf. He ran fast enough here to win pretty much any
AW handicap and will surely score again soon.
ATLANTIC QUEST (36) got into traffic problems which is the
norm for him in fields of twelve or more around a turn. But he still ran close
to his best. So he should have a big chance of winning the next time he hits a
field of 11 or less.
TAMAGIN MUST WIN SOON
I'd been hoping that TAMAGIN (36) would step up to a mile
at Lingfield as I felt sure it was his very best course and distance. He'd won
over shorter but would have been unbeaten in three tries over the course and
distance but for racing too keenly and getting beat a head on once occasion. So
I was very pleased to see him running in a mere class 4 handicap over a mile on
Lingfield's Polytrack last week. Back in April he'd earned a Listed class speed
rating from me when winning over this course and distance. And he would have
done so again had he not been hampered in the closing stages on his latest
outing.
Sure enough Tamagin again ran a seriously fast time. But,
after setting a searching gallop, he got caught by MINA A SALEM (36) close home.
Tamagin is a whole lot better than a class 4 performer.
What's more he's improving, which is not that surprising since he was still only
three when running here. If he runs over a mile on the Polytrack at Lingfield
next time I wouldn't oppose him. I'd support him at Kempton too, but he's run
three clunkers at Wolverhampton from three tries, so I'd be less keen on his
chances there.
Mina A Salem is also a very smart horse and was almost
certainly helped by the strong pace set by Tamagin. I say this because his
previous fastest run came over ten furlongs on the same course. In a more
normally run race I'm not at all sure Mina A Salem would be effective over a
mile at Lingfield. I reckon he's basically a ten furlong horse
PERUVIAN PRINCE MAY NEED SMALL FIELDS
PERUVIAN PRINCE (36) posted a Listed class time when
cruising home in a class 5 handicap on Wolverhampton's Polytrack. This was his
third win in a row and he was beginning to look almost unstoppable in the low
grade handicaps he's still eligible for until losing in a photo to JUST BOND
(36) next time. But the ting is Just Bond is also very smart to be racing in
such low grade races and would have won his last four Polytrack starts but for
hanging and losing narrowly on one occasion.
Both Peruvian Prince and Just Bond should win again.
However I do have one concern about Peruvian Prince, and that is his wins have
all come in fields of nine or less. He's met traffic problems several times in
bigger fields. This makes sense as he's described as 'compact' by Raceform and
horses below average size tend to come off worst in the traffic that occurs in
all races.
From a punting point of view I rather hope that Peruvian
Prince now hits several races where a large number of runners line up. Then we
can get a nice price about him when he returns to a small field.
CALIFORNIA LAWS TOUGH TO BEAT AT SOUTHWELL
CALIFRONIA LAWS (36) extended his unbeaten run at Southwell
to three with a win in fast time last week. Clearly he's a smart horse on a slow
surface like Southwell's Fibresand as his only other win came on heavy going on
turf. The only real problem he faces now is that his handicap mark is getting
high enough to exclude him from all but a few of the generally low grade races
staged at Southwell. So his connections may be forced to run him on Polytrack,
if only to keep him ticking over till another opportunity at Southwell arises.
When he returns to the course I'd be wary of betting against him. And if the
going is really soft in the Spring he'll be tough to beat when switching back to
turf.
JIMMY THE GUESSER (36) pulled a long way clear of the rest
to take second and seemed to appreciate the cut back to six furlongs. He should
be able to win a similar race over the distance soon.
|