|
LUCKY STORY TOUGH TO BEAT IN CHAMPION STAKES
The QEII is a very odd race. It's run over a mile, but the track is so stiff
and the early pace invariably so fast that it frequently falls to a middle
distance horse. In winning the big race this year, RAKTI (45) became the
eleventh victor in the last5 15 years to have previously paced over a mile and a
quarter. In fact, both Rakti and last year's winner Falbrav had previously
scored in Group 1 company at a mile and a half.
Rakti equaled the biggest speed figures I've awarded this season, matching
the marks I gave to Azamour for his win in the Irish Champion Stakes and to
Doyen for his success in the Hardwicke Stakes. He's clearly a seriously good
horse, and with Falbrav now retired, he looks right on track to take his big
target of the season, the Hong Kong Cup in December.
The bookies have now introduced Rakti as favourite for the Breeders' Cup
Mile. But, as I see it, the idea of him going for that race is plain daft and
I'm sure his shrewd connections only floated the idea due to post-race euphoria.
Rakti,a very high strung horse, benefited from being allowed to go down to the
start early at Ascot. The one meeting where that would never be allowed is the
Breeders' Cup. The horses have to endure a lengthy parade, walking up and then
down past the grandstand. In addition, there is a whole world of difference
between the QEII, which suits ten furlong horses, and the Breeders' Cup Mile,
which suits European sprinters due to the slow early pace at which it is run.
Rakti would almost certainly boil over in the long parade in Texas, pull like a
train against the slow early pace, have trouble negotiating the very tight turns
on the seven furlong circuit and then get outpaced as the sprint to the line
began. In my opinion it's 100-1 against him even reaching the first four there.
LUCKY STORY (44) ran a big race to finish second, demonstrating the he needs
a greater test of stamina than he got in the slow run Prix du Mouilin last time.
The step up to ten furlongs for the Champion Stakes is a very logical move and
it's hard to see what could beat him in that race. The Champion stakes is often
a soft Group 1 these days, due to its close proximity to new and more valuable
alternative races for horses that might otherwise contest it. It offers Lucky
Story the best chance of gaining the Group 1 win he deserves before presumably
being bundled off to stud.
Refuse To Bend (42) ran bang up to form by finishing third. He's been very well
placed (and a bit lucky) to win four Group 1 races, seeing that he's never run a
speed figure better than a good Group 2 winner would earn. I don't know where he
goes next but hopefully it won't be to the Breeders' Cup. He's surely
demonstrated enough times by now that he simply can't handle a tight track like
Lone Star Park.
Nayyir (41) always seems to run his race and will try to make it eighth time
lucky in Group 1 company in the Prix Foret. He might just take that race, but I
suspect that his best shot of finally winning at the highest level would be back
in the Dubai Duty Free next March. I've always believed that a horse is at its
best at the outermost limits of its stamina, so I reckon the nine furlongs of
the Duty Free will suit Nayyir a whole lot better than the seven furlongs of the
Foret.
At this time of year you tend to see some fast handicappers emerge from the
woodwork in relatively low grade races as they prep fro the big end of season
handicaps. BLUE TROJAN (38) seems to fit neatly into this category after his win
in fast time at Kempton.
Blue Trojan seems to be one of those odd horses that is at their best
following a very recent race. All his wins since his maiden success have come
off a break of seven days or less. I'd also speculate that he is not at his best
on tracks with a significant downhill section in them. His trainer said as much
after his loss at Goodwood back in May. Even the prolonged 1 in 60 downhill
gradient on the Polytrack at Lingfield seems to cause him to run a bit below
form. In any event, it looks significant that Blue Trojan has now had four runs
since his maiden win on tracks without a big downhill section in them off a
break of a week or less and won every single time.
If Blue Trojan makes the cut in the Cambridgeshire and has a race within the preceding
week, I wouldn't discount his chances. In the meantime, if he's brought back
again quickly for another run I'd be wary of opposing him on any relatively flat
track.
A horse with an even bigger chance in the first leg of the Autumn double is
ST ANDREWS (41) who banged out a big Group 2 speed figure for the second time in
two tries on softer ground. He bolted up by seven lengths from a strong field at
Haydock and would surely be a good thing for the Cambridgeshire if the going
rode yielding or softer as it does about a third of the time for the big race.
If here were mine I'd be thinking of the Group 2 Premio Ribot over in Italy in
November for St Andrews. It often comes up soft for that race.
REGAL SETTING (40) gets my vote for being the best handicapped horse in
training following his win at Haydock. He lost both his seasonal debuts so far
but is unbeaten in all his other starts and earned a rating from me that would
take many Group 2 contests here. Long term, Regal Setting looks an interesting
prospect for Cup races next season. In the meantime though his trainer, Sir Mark
Prescott, will surely indulge in his specialty of winning a bunch of handicaps
in a row with such a favorably weighted runner.
Runner-up BIG MOMENT (40) has run close in a whole stack of big races both on
the flat and over hurdles. He showed here that he's as good as ever and ran a
seriously good trial for the Cesarewitch. If he fails to win there I'd bear him
in mind for a valuable staying hurdle soon after.
TRANCE (38) ran a big race to finish third, well clear of the race. He's also
in the Cesarewitch, but I doubt he'll be winning there because of the huge
field. Trance only faced six rivals here, and that seems to suit him. According
to my research, most horses that require small fields are best in races with 11
or fewer starters. Prior to this run Trance had won three of the five times he'd
run in races with 11 runners or less but lost all ten times he'd raced in bigger
fields. He won in fast time over a mile on the AW, so I'll be very interested in
his chances if he returns to the sand, even at a much shorter distance than the
14 furlongs he ran over here.
CAMROSE (38) is another unexposed type who won a 12 furlong Classified Stakes
on the same card in equally fast time. The three year old clearly improved for
the step up in distance and is looking interesting for one of the big Autumn
handicaps.
Camrose only just beat the promising Godolphin three year old ELMUSTANSER
(38) home. Elmustanser ran a bit green last time and may still have suffered
from lack of experience on what was only his fourth lifetime start. He's a
brother to Dubai World Cup winner Almutawakel and will no doubt be run on the
dirt in Dubai during the winter. I can see him developing into a useful
performer over there. He ran a time here that would win most Listed races and
quite a few Group 3's. So, providing he gets the fast ground dirt-bred runners
invariably need, he could easily win something decent on grass before then.
Yet another progressive young handicapper is STRAW BEAR (37) who I mentioned
here after his last start. He went and ran away with a Haydock handicap and may
well be capable of running quicker yet.
KEHAAR (39) could be described as a progressive young handicapper after his
win in fast time at Ascot. But I doubt that we'll be seeing him run in a
handicap again. Kehaar is a seriously smart seven furlong Group class performer
who looks a very interesting prospect for the big races at what his connection
feel is his specialist distance next year.
MAZUNA (38) and MY RENEE (38) ran decent speed figures to fight out the
finish of the Princess Royal Stakes at Ascot. Clearly Mazuna has improved
significantly since they learned she needs to be held up till the last minute. I
can see her winning another Group race before the season is out. She will
apparently get her chance in next month's Premio Lydia Tesio, recently upgraded
to Group 1 status, at the Capannelle in Italy next month.
My Renee missed work through a stone bruise a week before the race, so she
did well to go under by a mere short head. If the photo had gone the other way
this would have been her fourth win in four tries at 12 furlongs. Her
connections are apparently considering a trip to America to ensure she gets the
firm ground they feel she needs. I assume they're thinking in terms of the Long
Island Handicap at Aqueduct in November. That race is run over 12 furlongs.
It's not often you see a horse that's won a Group 2 and finished second in
two Group 1's contesting a claimer. So it's not that surprising only Carroll
claimed ENDLESS SUMMER (38) for one of his owners when the horse ran for a
15,000 pound tag a few starts back. It looked like money well spent at Leicester
when the old boy won a five furlong class D handicap in a time that would give
him a shot in a big sprint handicap. He's now gone on to win again, confirming
that view.
BLUE MAUVE (37) is another sprinter that put up a fast time recently in a low
grade race. He lowered the course record for five furlongs at Pontefract thanks
to lightning fast ground and a tailwind. It seems that he's a short runner and
needs a super fast surface to even get the minimum distance. He'd be kind of
interesting for this reason over the minimum trip during the winter on the
Polytrack. Meanwhile, if he hits really firm ground again he's very capable of
following up this win.
Yet another fast sprinter is JOHNNY EBENEEZER (39) who ran a Group 3 class
time to win at Haydock. His trainer seems to feel that he needs a smart jockey
who can kid him along. Hayley Turner seems to fit that bill and is clearly an up
and coming rider. Previously the connections had always tried to book Dettori.
Now it looks like they've found an able substitute.
My read of Johnny Ebeneezer is that he can win in big fields but is best in
races with less than a dozen starters. He's won the last four times he's run in
grass sprints in fields that small.
PIC UP STICKS (39) ran equally fast to win a valuable handicap sprint at
Ripon. I'd be wating a while to follow him though. All his three wins since his
maiden success have come on one of his first two starts following a lay-off.
He's won three times out of five in these circumstances and went close in the
Wokingham in one of his losses. I imagine he'll be shipping over to Nad Al Sheba
again this winter for the fast ground. He'll be interesting in his first couple
of starts over there, and on his first two outings back in Britain next season
too.
FORWARD MOVE (31) lowered the juvenile record for at mile at Newmarket by
over a second when winning a maiden by five lengths. However, he had the
assistance of a tailwind which was speeding the runners up by a huge 1.8 seconds
a mile by my estimates. So I wouldn't go overboard about him. However, he is
almost certainly at least Listed class and could be better than that, so he's
worth keeping an eye on.
MOTH BALL (32) is another two year old worth watching following his win in
Listed class time in a Brighton nursery. Moth Ball beat the smart Yajbill the
only other time he's raced on a track with a significant downhill section (Goodwood).
It could be that he's best on tracks such as Brighton, Chepstow, Goodwood and
Lingfield. More likely his defeats at other venues have simply been due to the
fact that he got hampered when losing narrowly at Musselburgh and may not have
acted on the yielding ground at Warwick.
COUNTRY RAMBLER (35) won in surprisingly fast time for what was basically a
public exercise gallop against a single rival at Ripon. It could well be that he
wasn't getting home over longer trips in his previous couple of starts due to
pulling hard. In any event this was a Group 3 class performance, and I'd be
interested to see Country Rambler in a race around that level back at six
furlongs.
The big two year old races at Ascot continued the trend of ho hum times run
at Group level by juveniles.
Pastperformance (35) took the Royal Lodge, but I wouldn't fancy his chances
at Group 1 level.
Playful Act (33) won the Fillies Mile. She was allowed to set her own pace
which probably accounts for the slowish time. She ran a good deal quicker to
take the May Hill stakes, earning a Group 1 speed figure from me on that
occasion. The May Hill stakes has proven a terrific guide to the Fillies Mile
over the years. In fact, if Calando hadn't been denied a clear run and lost by a
neck in 1999 and Midnight Air hadn't been disqualified in 1991, seven of the
eleven May Hill winners to run in this race over the last 27 years would now
have won.
INTO THE DARK MOVES INTO THE TOP DIVISION
Having tipped INTO THE DARK (43) at 40-1 for the St Leger, it is with
somewhat mixed feelings that I report he's just gone and run a time that in my
estimation would have given him a comfortable win in the final classic - if only
he'd run.
I've whittered on about Into The Dark an awful lot on my website, noting how
he ran so fast at Newmarket, and how the form of that race has worked out so
incredibly well. Now it looks clear that he's set to be Godolphin's big older
horse for next year. In the meantime I think he almost certainly needs what the
Americans and Australians call 'seasoning'. That is, he needs to have a horse
somewhere near his class make a run at him in a race that requires a major
effort on his part to repel. So far he's won four times out of four without ever
really breaking sweat.
In my experience horses like Into The Dark tend to lose if they're simply
thrown into the deep end in a big international Group 1 against older horses for
the first time. They may be faster than their rivals but they get shocked at the
strength of the challenges that are made and normally run below their best. I
guess the best approach is to simply get that run out of the way and move on
from there. After all, Godolphin have shown in the past that they're not all
precious and commercial about protecting a horse's unbeaten record in order to
sustain its stud value. In any event, I await future developments with great
interest.
Runner-up Percussionist (39) confirmed that he's just a bit shy of Group 1
class by running a five length second. He's capable of winning a Group 2 or 3
race but I rather suspect he's going to be over-ambitiously placed and over bet
in his next few starts, so I can't recommend following him.
BONECRUSHER (39) ran a big race to be third. A lot of people see him as
'quirky' and unreliable. But I note with interest that he would have won both
the previous times he'd run on soft ground if he hadn't been an unlucky short
head loser in the City and Suburban handicap. This makes three big runs out of
three on soft ground for Bonecrusher. He also ran a big race on the All Weather
the only time he tried the surface, so it may well be he simply needs a surface
that takes the emphasis off finishing speed. I'll be very interested in his
chances next time he encounters squidgy going or the AW.
Funfair Wane (42) ran a time that would win most Group races when taking the
Ayr Gold Cup. he thing is, there are gazillions of fast sprinters in Britain and
there's nothing between the Group sprinters and the handicappers. As a result,
with huge fields for all the top sprints, and with the draw and luck in running
playing such a big part, it's not easy for even a very smart sprinter to win
more than once in a while. For this reason, quick as he is, I can't really
recommend following Funfair Wane.
Similar comments apply to The Tatling (42) who took a Group 3 sprint at
Newbury in equally fast time.
We're finally beginning to see some decent winners of juvenile pattern races.
PRINCE CHARMING (36) certainly fits into this category after his win in fast
time in Ayr's Harry Roseberry Stakes.
All of Prince Charming's wins to date have been on yielding or softer ground.
His dam seems to be a terrific influence for slower surfaces. The vast majority
of the wins scored by her other six successful progeny were on yielding or
softer turf or on a deep and slow artificial surface.
Trainer John Gosden has said that Prince Charming should run just as well on
a firmer surface, but the balance of probability says we shouldn't bet on that
till there's some supporting evidence. Meanwhile though if it comes up soft for
the Middle Park Prince Charming would have a serious chance. He rates as one of
the better two year olds off this run.
MARY READ (34) ran a good race to chase Prince Charming home and would be
quick enough to take a Group race against her own sex at the minimum distance -
if only one were available. A real speedball, she may well be at her best when
able to dominate a small field from the front. So far she's won two out of two
in fields of less than 12 since her debut and lost all her other starts.
Sir Mark Prescott isn't known as 'the handicap king' for nothing. He's a
master at playing the system and getting a horse well handicapped. Now he's got
himself a three year old that is so incredibly well handicapped that I can see
him winning something like half a dozen races in a row. The horse I'm talking
about is CIRCASSIAN (38) who earned a Group 3 class speed rating when romping
away with a mere class E handicap at Yarmouth the other day off a mark of just
67.
Circassian lost narrowly (earning a rating of 36) when he Prescott first
employed his trademark maneuver of stepping him up to a longer distance. He ran
fast enough that day to merit a mention here. He improved on that run here and
must surely be the best handicapped horse in training. I wouldn't oppose him in
the immediate future. This is just the kind of horse Prescott can bring up through
the ranks and win a big handicap with.
Circassian has in fact gone on to win another race now. But he's not the only
well handicapped three year old stayer Sir Mark Prescott has in his yard. REGAL
SETTING (37) is clearly another after his win against an unusually strong field
for a 0-85 handicap at Nottingham.
Regal Setting isn't as well handicapped as Circassian. He still looks capable
of winning a few more times before the end of the season though.
Runner-up KIND EMPEROR (35) is kind of interesting. There aren't that many
meetings at Yarmouth, but he was running at the track for the tenth time in a
row. He's only ever won at the course, so I assume he runs here because he has
had a history of muscle problems and Yarmouth is the nearest dead flat track to
Newmarket, where he is trained.
Probably due to the muscle problems, Kind Emperor had previously shown his
best form when fresh prior to this run. In fact he's won three times out of
three over a mile plus at Yarmouth when he's been laid off for five weeks or
more. His other win was also at Yarmouth and was the second start off a break
(the first being in a sprint).
I note with interest that there is a meeting at Yarmouth on the fifth of
November, and another on the 16th of October. I'd be very interested if Kind
Emperor were kept fresh for the November meeting and still rather interested if
he came back to Yarmouth for their October fixture.
Prescott wheeled out yet another improving three year old in a handicap at
Ayr with STRAW BEAR (36). Using his patented step up in distance maneuver,
Prescott delivered a useful looking winner who remains eligible for races he
should be able to dominate.
Sir Mark even pulled off his little wheeze in a nursery when COMIC STRIP (31)
stepped up to a mile and ran a useful time to win at Ayr. Comic Strip has now
won three of his four starts and could easily take a Listed race.
One of the fastest times of the last week was put up by a horse that I
confess I just don't understand. This was YOUNG MR GRACE (38) who ran a pattern class
time to take a good class C handicap at the big Ayr meeting. Maybe Young Mr
Grace is best in small fields. Perhaps he needs a stiff track or soft ground to
make it a real test. I don't know. All I do know is that he has won or lost by
less than a length in five of his last seven races. He looks capable of making
his mark in some of the better handicaps.
Runner-up JAZZ SCENE (37) ran fourth by five and a half lengths in a Group 3
a couple of starts back and has frequently tackled some pretty hot company. He
showed that he handles heavy ground here and that he might well appreciate a bit
further than the eight furlongs of this race with the way he stayed on. He looks
like a likely winner in the near future.
Smart three year old maiden winners are rare at this time of year. But BATIK
(36) certainly fits into that category after her recent victory at Bath. She was
scrubbed along from a long way out but finally found her obvious stamina coming
into play in the closing stages. She was backward according to Raceform when
third over a hopelessly inadequate mile on her only previous start and looks a
likely candidate to take one of the many Listed races for fillies that abound at
this time of year. In fact, looking at the official ratings of the second and
third (74 and 70) it looks likely that Batik may be awarded a mark of 80 or even
lower. That would make her eligible for a very ordinary handicap that she should
be able to win with ease next time.
MOORS MYTH (36), a fast and wide margin winner of a maiden at Musselburgh the
same day, looks set to be even more leniently handicapped than Batik, since the
second and third in his race had official ratings of 47 and 49. He has clearly
improved for his first few starts and should be tough to beat in a class D or
lower handicap next time.
Clive Brittain has a nice juvenile filly on his hands in AMALIE (33) who
posted a Listed/Group 3 class time to win a Redcar maiden impressively. I'd
think long and hard before opposing her next time out. She could easily be one
of the top two year old fillies.
JAY GEE'S CHOICE (36) bounced back to form to take a decent little Classified
Stakes at Pontefract. He's made all the running in all three wins he's scored so
far, and it seems to me he's probably best when able to dominate a small field
from the front like this. His three runs in fields of seven or less have
produced two wins and a second to the smart Mubeen. A small field for most
horses is 11 runners or less. But it's tough to tell whether this is small
enough for Jay Gee's Choice as his runs in fields between eight and 11 starters
have been over seven furlongs, and it may well be that he now needs a mile to do
his best. In any event, if he can be found another race with a field of 11 or
less soon I'd say he can follow up.
Runner-up NAMROC (36) did well to get so close after being outpaced when the
front runner quickened it up before the two furlong pole. he way he stayed on
suggests that he mat well improve over further than a mile. In any event, with
just three runs under his belt, Namroc is clearly a promising horse who looks
set to win soon.
Sights On Gold (39) ran a solid Group 3 rating to take Newbury's Arc Trial.
But he's now likely to step up into Group 2 company which my ratings and his
form indicate he's not quite up to. Runner-up IMPERIAL DANCER (38) doesn't have
such problems, and had run quicker on his previous start, as well as on numerous
other occasions. He'd looked a good thing to win the race beforehand but he only
lost narrowly in what was a messy race. He still looks on target for a repeat of
last year's win in the Premio Roma. In fact anywhere he runs on a dead flat
galloping track I'd rate him a threat.
BEWARE OF CAESAR, HE'S THE THE TOP TWO YEAR OLD
CAESAR BEWARE (38) had a strong tailwind to help him, so many may be inclined
to discount the fact that he broke the course record when winning the valuable
St Leger Yearling Sales stakes at Doncaster. But the fact is he ran only a
fraction of a second slower in comparison with my standard times than the winner
of the Portland Handicap, the very next race. The Portland Handicap is one of
the top sprints, and the top sprint handicappers are basically as fast as the
Group sprinters. So, any way you cut it, even incorporating the biggest
adjustment for a tailwind that I've ever used, Caesar Beware's run ranks as a
solid Group 1 performance for a two year old, and the best we've seen anywhere
in Europe so far this season.
Caesar Beware has of course run awfully fast before, so his performance was
not that big a surprise. It's just a pity he's a gelding which means he won't
get a shot at the Group 1 glory that the clock says he deserves. At least he's
eligible for the Group 2 Mill Reef stakes at Newbury on the 18th of September.
He shouldn't have much trouble winning that race on this run. After which the
Redcar two year old Trophy offers him another shot at a big prize. If things go
as they should Caesar Beware may well end up the top two year old and head the
Free handicap. Then again, I dare say the official handicapper might be
pressured to massage his figures and push Caesar Beware's rating down a bit. The
idea of a gelding heading the Free handicap might just be too much to take for
some.
DISTINCTLY GAME (35), the runner-up, is looking rather interesting now. His
trainer said that the horse was still a bit weak and immature following his
first win but that he was a seriously good horse. He was proven right here.
Clearly it was a smart move giving Distinctly Game a two month mid-season break,
as he now appears to have matured and improved, just as his trainer must have
hoped. It looks clear too that the step up to six furlongs was a good move.
With just one win in six starts and losing runs on the AW and a nursery
handicap, Distinctly Game doesn't look like a Group horse on paper. But that's
what the clock says he is. So I'm rather hoping he jumps up to Listed or Group 3
company next time. He'd likely start at big odds but would have a terrific
chance of winning. In a nursery he'd be a near cert.
In the previous race on the same card, one of the season's most valuable
nurseries, Godolphin continued their new policy of running good horses in
handicaps with SWAN NEBULA (33) who put up a time that would win many Group
races for two year old fillies to score clearly.
Swan Nebula was the latest in a long line of nursery winners this season to
run a pattern class time. I don't quite know why this new trend has developed so
strongly this season. But it certainly makes for some prospective value bets
when the fast nursery winners - Cupid's Glory, Coleorton Dancer, Merchant,
Nufoos and Swan Nebula - step up to pattern company.
YAJBILL (33) continued the fast nursery winner theme when winning by five
lengths at Epsom. He's won both his starts in pattern class time since having
visors applied and ought to be given a shot at some black type now. His pedigree
says pretty clearly that he will stay a mile, so it would be interesting to see
him go up a furlong or two from the six furlongs of this race. He's own by
Sheikh Ahmed Al Maktoum, so I imagine he'll be switching to Godolphin at the end
of the season. That being so, I'd imagine his owner will be keen to test him in
pattern company soon.
Another pretty quick two year old won on the same day at Epsom. This was
INTRIGUED (32) who took a maiden over the extended mile in unusually fast time.
Trainer Sir Mark Prescott has Intrigued entered in a bunch of Group races
including the Fillies' Mile. The time only puts her around Listed class, but she
won by a big margin and may well be able to improve on this.
This has been quite a week for two year olds. According to my ratings, not
only did we see the fastest two year old colt in Caesar Beware, we also saw the
fastest filly in PLAYFUL ACT (37).
Playful Act is a sister to Percussionist who was fancied for the Leger and a
half sister to Echoes In Eetrnity who won the Park Hill stakes over the Leger
trip at the same meeting. So she almost certainly benefited from the strong
gallop set by Cassydora and Red Peony. Her long term target is the Oaks next
year, and one has to wonder whether she might not get done for speed over a mile
in a race run at a normal pace. We'll get the chance to find out in the Fillies'
Mile.
QUEEN OF POLAND (37) and MAIDS CAUSEWAY (37) who finished close up in second
and third, are the obvious candidates to beat Playful Act in the Fillies' Mile.
Both are clearly high class fillies well capable of winning a Group 1. The
Marcel Boussac looks a tempting target for either of them. The 33-1 offered
about the pair for the 1000 Guineas looks awfully generous to me.
On the other hand the 10-1 offered about Etlaala (31) for the 2000 Guineas
looks decidedly stingy after his win in ho-hum time in the Champagne stakes. I
guess all he could do was win and remain unbeaten, but I'd need to see a whole
lot more before being convinced he's Group 1 class. And, seeing the host of fast
maiden and nursery winners now due to switch to Group company, I rather fancy
that Etlaala is going to get beat next time out.
MIllenary (39) and Kasthari (39) produced a decent speed figure when dead
heating for the Doncaster Cup. But it was only average for the class, so I doubt
either are worth following. Similar comments apply to Celtic Mill (39) and
Talbot Avenue who went 1-2 in Doncaster's Scarborough stakes.
The St Leger was even slower, thanks to the slow pace set by the winner Rule
Of Law (31). All the result showed is that he can sprint the last few furlongs
better than his rivals - hardly surprising seeing that his dam was a sprinter
and that her other two foals were sprinters. I have a horrible feeling this
year's Leger is going to set a trend in terms of pace. Today's horses are just
not bred to get the Leger trip in a turly run race. It could well be that we're
going to follow the trend that's been set in America, where the horses are even
more speedily bred than they are here. Over there the jockeys almost never ask
their mounts to go any sort of an early pace in races at a mile and a half or
more.
One race that was run in above average time at Doncaster was the Mallard
Stakes. This was won by the progressive three year old LOST SOLDIER THREE (38).
My ratings say Luca Cumani is right to say Lost Soldier Three could develop into
a Cup horse next year. Meanwhile it's interesting to reflect on how good Into
The Dark must be. Into The Dark beat Lost Soldier Three and a whole host of
subsequent winners on his last start while winning in fast time. He's looking
more and more interesting as time goes by.
Another fast race was the Conditions event won by SECRET CHARM (40). Barry
Hills had rested this filly since the Spring when he said she was not right
(even so she finished close up fifth in the UK and Irish 1000 Guineas). He's
clearly got her spot on now though. Her next target is the Joel stakes at
Newmarket apparently. That's a Group 3 over a mile against colts which seems
about right since Secret Charm earned a speed rating between Group 3 and Group 2
class here. Long term, if she's kept in training next year, Secret Charm might
well be able to take a Group 1 against her own sex, especially if she stays ten
furlongs as Barry Hills once suggested. I can understand the need to go for the
Group 3 race first though. A group win of any sort will boost Secret Charm's
stud value massively.
MILK IT MICK (39) finished a close second to Secret Charm. He clearly appreciated
the switch to firmer ground and the step back up to a mile. If he sticks to
seven furlongs or a mile now and gets the fast ground he needs I can see Milk It
Mick finally scoring another Group win soon. The Joel stakes looks a logical
target for him too.
Another possible candidate for the Joel stakes is FREE TRIP (37) who earned a
Listed class rating from me when winning a hot class C handicap at Sandown.
Jockey Richard Huges said afterwards that his mount was better in a small field.
My studies show that for most horses anything under 12 runners counts as a small
field (there is an big increase in interference when field size jumps from 11 to
12, and it's the increased traffic that generally causes horse like Free Trip to
dislike big fields). Free Trip has won all three times he's encountered fields
this small. His best chance of finding small fields would be in Listed and Group
company. Handicaps tend to feature more runners. So, since he's run fast enough
to win in pattern company, the step up in grade would seem a logical move.
At Goodwood ALKAADHEM (40) ran a rating that puts him in with a real shot in
the Prix Dollar when taking a ten furlong Group 3. He's now won both times he's
run ten furlongs, so the nine and three quarter furlongs of the Prix Dollar
should be fine. Alkaadhem has been touted as a potentially top class horse on
several occasions. Now, at ten furlongs, he finally may prove all the hype to be
right.
For a horse that is much better on a straight course, according to the form
book and his trainer, SALSELON (38) ran a good race to miss being second to
Alkhaadem by only a short head on such a roller-coaster of a track. Luca
Cumani's belief that Saleselon would be suited by a step up to ten furlongs was
borne out by this run. I note with interest that he has Salselon entered up in
the Champion stakes at Newmarket. That race is often a weak Group 1 these days.
So, seeing it is run up the straight and over what seems to be Salselon's
optimum trip, I'm hoping Salselon turns up. He could win at a big price there.
One great thing about speed ratings is that they sometimes alert you to big
performances in the most unexpected of races. My favourite is when I find a
really fast time in a selling race. That situation usually produces some
excellent priced winners in non-sellers. Another, even less frequent big rating
sometimes occurs in a maiden handicap. Maiden handicaps are generally as bad as
seller. But not the one won at Bath recently by POLAR TRYST (36). This five year
old came close to the track record when romping away by six lengths from a
decent Loder-trained rival. In doing so he ran a time that in my estimation
would win many Listed contests.
When last seen out Polar Tryst went down by a head to Analogy who went on to
become a useful staying hurdler. He had Grey Clouds back in third, and that won
has gone on to win three times since as well as going close in decent class C
handicaps.
Polar Tryst ran off a mark of 62 at Bath. Even if the handicapper gives him a
huge penalty he'll still be eligible for races well below his true class, so he
looks well worth following.
At Goodwood ETTRICK WATER (39) won for the third time in his last four
starts. He's obviously improved since being gelded and may well have a big race
in him. He showed here that he doesn't need to dominate or require a small
field, and that's something new for him really. Could be that's why my ratings
say he continued his improvement here. In other words, he's gaining confidence
and getting a bit more courageous as he keeps on racking up all these wins.
Over jumps the trend of exceptionally fast novice chasers continued when
ISARD III (40) just managed to get by SHALAKO (40) at Bangor. Shalko had already
earned a rating of 39 from me and I thought he was a near certainty but Isard
III proved me wrong.
Isard II failed to win in three tries over fences in the 2003/2003 season but
encountered yielding or soft ground every time. It looks clear that he needs a
bit more bounce in the ground to clear fences effectively for he's now won all
three of his completed starts over fences this term on good or faster going. If
he were mine I'd be putting him away around October when the softer ground tends
to start then bringing him back for the Sun Alliance Chase at the Cheltenham
Festival. The ground is almost guaranteed to be fast there and Isard III has
shown he can run quick enough to win that race.
Shalako once again showed how smart he is on fast ground and I wouldn't want
to oppose him in the immediate future as long as he gets it. Long term, he looks
a good bet to take a Graded novice chase if he gets his ground.
OLLIE MAGERN (36) was yet another novice chaser to run a fast time. This was
on his chasing debut at Stratford. Ollie Magern went close at the last Aintree
Festival over hurdles. If this were a normal season I'd say he was a good thing
for the valuable novice chase coming up at Market Rasen next month. But with so
many smart first season chasers around I'll wait for the day to see the strength
of the competition. In a way I rather hope that Ollie Magern does come up
against some of the very fast novice chasers we've seen so far in that race.
He'd surely lose then be a better price when he runs in lesser company
afterwards.
TOP SPRINTERS ARE A VINTAGE BUNCH
Looking at the results of the big sprints this year it's tempting to conclude
that we have a moderate crop of sprinters. But the times they've been achieving
actually suggest this is a truly vintage crop. The only reason the top sprinters
seem to be taking turns beating each other is that there are so many
exceptionally fast ones.
The Stanleyvet Sprint Cup at Haydock confirmed this view for the winner TANTE
ROSE (45) equaled the biggest speed rating I've awarded in Britain, Ireland or
France all season.
It now seems clear that Tante Rose doesn't really get seven furlongs well
enough to win in top company. She won the Fred Darling stakes over seven, but
she only earned a speed rating of 35 while doing so. She's lost the other seven
times she's gone seven furlongs. It also looks obvious that Tante Rose is best
when fresh. Like many horses she seems to show her best on her first two starts
each season and then requires a break of five weeks or more in order to run well
again. I guess you can argue about Tante Rose's ability to get seven furlongs,
so it seems reasonable that she's to go for the Prix de la Foret over that trip
next time. Personally I'll be betting she doesn't stay there. But I have to
concede it's possible seeing that she has six weeks to freshen up before the big
day.
The horse I'll be looking to beat Tante Rose at Longchamp is MONSIEUR BOND
(41) who finished fifth behind her at Haydock. I've been banging on about this
horse all season, saying he's the best seven furlong runner in training and that
he has had his name all over the Prix de la Foret ever since that huge win he
scored at the Curragh back in April.
I confess Monsieur Bond disappointed in the six and a half furlong Prix
Maurice de Gheest. But I think I now know why. It seems to me that Monsieur Bond
is not at his best in very crowded fields. All his wins have come in contests
with 15 runners or less. He's run unplaced in all six pattern races he's
contested with bigger fields. But when there have been 15 runners or less he's
run much better. As I've mentioned before, I think Monsieur Bond needs good or
slower ground to be effective at six furlongs but can handle any surface at
seven. With that proviso his form at six and seven furlongs in fields of 15 or
less now shows six wins in seven tries, with the loss being a most unlucky one
when he was severely impeded.
SOMNUS (45) finished runner-up to Tante Rose, going down by only a short
head. And I suspect he suffers from the opposite problem to Monsieur Bond.
Monsieur Bond seems to have trouble avoiding traffic in big fields. But Somnus
appears to need the faster early pace normally generated by a big field to run
to his best. In fields of nine runners or less Somnus has blanked in four
starts, running unplaced in three of them. But in bigger fields at his
specialist distance of six furlongs (or six and a half) he's won eight times out
of 11.
What's interesting is that in his last two starts Somnus has now run up to
his best on ground that my going allowances say was actually on the fast side of
good. So it would seem his reputation for preferring softer ground is all wrong.
After the race trainer Tim Easterby said of Somnus "They keep slagging
him off - I don’t know why. He’s been the best sprinter around for two years
but nobody gives him credit." Looking at my ratings, I have to agree with
Easterby. Some sprinters occasionally run as fast or nearly as fast as he does,
but no sprinter has earned so many big speed figures from me as Somnus in the
last two years. I'm just thankful the horse is a gelding because it means he'll
still be around next season.
Third placed PATAVELLIAN (44) won the Prix Abbaye last year and looks to have
been specially laid out for a repeat bid this season. On this run it's going to
take something very special to beat him at Longchamp, and I just don't see any
horses around with the speed to get by him over five furlongs. As long as the
ground isn't firm on the day I think he has a huge chance of pulling off the
double.
I dare say most people will now be writing off ONE COOL CAT (40) as just
another Coolmore hype horse after his sixth place finish. But my speed ratings
reveal that he actually continued the improvement he's shown on each of his
starts this season.
Seeing that he's totally bred for dirt, it could very well be that the reason
One Cool Cat shows such amazing ability on his home gallops at Balydoyle is that
they are dirt. Yes they have grass gallops at Ballydoyle, but I'd bet good money
it's on the dirt surface Michael Dickinson helped build for them that One Cool
Cat has been flying.
I've just watched many of America's best sprinters run in the Forego handicap
at Saratoga, and I tell you this is not a vintage crop of sprinters in the
states. One Cool Cat has been running well against a genuinely exceptional bunch
of sprinters in Europe. And he's probably been doing it on the wrong surface. So
I say forget about that Prix Abbaye entry. Take One Cool Cat to America and
shoot for the Breeders' Cup Sprint on dirt. He could go off at enormous odds
there, but I reckon he'd be worth having a punt on.
Earlier this season the big theme was fast times by three year olds in
handicaps. Now the two year olds seem to be following suit with a series of big
speed ratings earned in nurseries.
Normally you see a pattern class speed figure only once or twice a season in
nursery handicaps. But we're only in the second month of these races so far and
NUFOOS (31) was the fifth nursery winner to record a rating that high (the
others being Cupid's Glory, Coleorton Dancer (twice) and Merchant).
Nufoos ran in pattern company on her previous two starts and trainer Mark
Johnston says the aim is to step back up to that level and try to win a Listed
race. That seems a logical move, though I imagine Johnston must also be eyeing
the valuable Jersey Lily nursery at Newmarket which is restricted to fillies.
Satchem (32) showed that it's quite possible to step up from this year's
unusually competitive nurseries to win against the freakishly slow bunch of
horses we've seen so far in juvenile Group contests. She performed the feat in
the Group 3 Sirenia stakes, but I wouldn't bet on her winning at this level
again. The fast maiden and nursery winners are now stacking up and are surely
going to overwhelm the vast majority of two year old Group winners we've seen so
far.
A good example of what I'm talking about is the Godolphin juvenile SUNDAY
SYMPHONY (34) who banged out a very decent Group class speed figure when
powering away with a Thirsk maiden over a mile. He lowered the two year old
track record for the trip by over half a second and would have beaten it by more
than a second if Thirsk hadn't switched to electric timing. The old hand-timed
record was set by Ivan Luis who went on to win a Group 2 and place in multiple
Group 1's. Sunday Symphony looks set to go the same way. He is entered in the
Epsom Derby and bred to get every yard of the trip. The logical target for him
would surely be the ten furlong Criterium de Saint Cloud in November. He'd also
be rather interesting in the Racing Post Trophy. I doubt that he'd get beaten
before those races if he sticks to a mile or more.
The three year old ANOTHER BOTTLE (37) won for the third time in his last
four starts in the prestigious Ripon Rowels Handicap. He's improving steadily
and could easily take down a big handicap at some time.
Runner-up WILL HE WISH (37) is eight years old but is still plenty useful.
His trainer, Steve Gollings, says he's best with some cut in the ground, which
there was here. If the going stays squidgy I'd bet on the old boy winning next
time, as long as he doesn't go for one of the really big handicaps.
Win machine GOODBYE MR BOND (37) won for the fifth time in the last three
months when scoring at Haydock. He clocked a decent time here and his speed
figures are on an upward swing, so I suspect he hasn't stopped winning yet.
I'm not fond of sprinters because so many factors that would be of small
consideration in longer races (e.g. the draw, luck in running, variations in the
going from one side of the course to another) can easily make the difference
between victory and defeat. However, I just have to make note of old-timer
MAROMITO (37) who put up a seriously good time to take a low grade sprint
handicap at Salisbury. He has apparently had a pedal bone problem, which
accounts for some gaps in his record. But he's clearly over it now and is going
to be hard to stop next time seeing that his official handicap mark still allows
him into races well below his true level.
Another sprinter worth noting is FOREVER PHOENIX (39) who scored in unusually
fast time at Haydock. Forever Phoenix has been banging out Group 3 class speed
figures all season, but this effort was slightly better than anything she's put
up so far. It could well be that she's not quite as good in the height of summer
when fillies are coming in an out of season. In this regard it's interesting to
note she's won five of the last seven times she's run in sprints from September
to May. She certainly looks interesting for the upcoming Portland Handicap.
At the other end of the distance scale I have to make mention of OCEAN AVENUE
(37) who clocked a fast time to win a decent 0-85 handicap at Kempton. This was
his fifth win in ten tries at twelve furlongs or more. He looks capable of
winning something better.
Runner-up BLAZE OF COLOUR (36) is only three and looks very progressive on my
speed figures. His last four ratings are 21, 28, 33 and now 36. Clearly he is
improving with racing and ought to be able to win something soon.
ROSS COMM IS A TOP CLASS NOVICE CHASER
Over jumps, ROSS COMM (41) continued the trend of exceptional novice chasers
that we've seen this summer. In fact, this Irish recruit ranks as the fastest of
the lot according to my speed ratings. This was his first run for Sue Smith, and
clearly she has improved him massively from his Irish form.
Ross Comm has now contested 11 races over fences, when you include his four
point to point starts, and eight hurdles, yet he has yet to make a jumping error
of any sort according to the form book - despite twice being asked to jump
around in huge fields at Fairyhouse which, as his jockey pointed out,
"takes some jumping". This kind of jumping ability is rare in a novice
chaser and should give Ross Comm a decided edge over the inexperienced jumpers
he'll continue to face for the remainder of this season.
It may seem silly to say this at such an early stage, but Ross Comm looks to
have a serious chance of winning the Sun Alliance Chase at the Cheltenham
Festival on this run.
Runner-up ITALIAN COUNSEL (36) won the valuable summer hurdle at Market Rasen
a year ago and showed that he's just as good over fences here. He did very well
to get to within 13 lengths of a top class chaser and looks a good thing to get
off the mark over fences next time.
PETER'S IMP (35) and COLLEGE CITY (34) ran remarkably fast for the grade when
finishing 1-2 in a Cartmel selling hurdle. The clock indicates that both are
capable of winning outside of selling class. This is a rare situation and one
that is frequently profitable. Punters seem to have a big bias against horses
stepping up from selling company to normal handicaps, so I'd bet on obtaining
value prices against the pair next time.
Peter's Imp has won four of the last five times he's run in selling and
claiming company on the flat and over hurdles. If he sticks to such races no
doubt he'll be odds-on. But he'd surely be a betting proposition in a bottom
rung handicap where he's not up for sale.
College City might actually offer some betting value if he sticks to selling
company. But he's still only five and his connections will surely not want to
risk losing him. So I imagine we'll be seeing him in a normal handicap next
time. If the going is yielding or softer I'd be interested in his chances. He's
won two of the three times he's encoutered a soft surface over hurdles since his
jumps debut and run second the other time.
|